Unpacking Failure Modes of Generative Policies: Runtime Monitoring of Consistency and Progress

Robot behavior policies trained via imitation learning are prone to failure under conditions that deviate from their training data. Thus, algorithms that monitor learned policies at test time and provide early warnings of failure are necessary to facilitate scalable deployment. We propose Sentinel, a runtime monitoring framework that splits the detection of failures into two complementary categories: 1) Erratic failures, which we detect using statistical measures of temporal action consistency, and 2) task progression failures, where we use Vision Language Models (VLMs) to detect when the policy confidently and consistently takes actions that do not solve the task. Our approach has two key strengths. First, because learned policies exhibit diverse failure modes, combining complementary detectors leads to significantly higher accuracy at failure detection. Second, using a statistical temporal action consistency measure ensures that we quickly detect when multimodal, generative policies exhibit erratic behavior at negligible computational cost. In contrast, we only use VLMs to detect failure modes that are less time-sensitive. We demonstrate our approach in the context of diffusion policies trained on robotic mobile manipulation domains in both simulation and the real world. By unifying temporal consistency detection and VLM runtime monitoring, Sentinel detects 18% more failures than using either of the two detectors alone and significantly outperforms baselines, thus highlighting the importance of assigning specialized detectors to complementary categories of failure. Qualitative results are made available at https://sites.google.com/stanford.edu/sentinel.

EquiBot: SIM(3)-Equivariant Diffusion Policy for Generalizable and Data Efficient Learning

Building effective imitation learning methods that enable robots to learn from limited data and still generalize across diverse real-world environments is a long-standing problem in robot learning. We propose EquiBot, a robust, data-efficient, and generalizable approach for robot manipulation task learning. Our approach combines SIM(3)-equivariant neural network architectures with diffusion models. This ensures that our learned policies are invariant to changes in scale, rotation, and translation, enhancing their applicability to unseen environments while retaining the benefits of diffusion-based policy learning such as multi-modality and robustness. We show in a suite of 6 simulation tasks that our proposed method reduces the data requirements and improves generalization to novel scenarios. In the real world, we show with in total 10 variations of 6 mobile manipulation tasks that our method can easily generalize to novel objects and scenes after learning from just 5 minutes of human demonstrations in each task.

EquivAct: SIM(3)-Equivariant Visuomotor Policies beyond Rigid Object Manipulation

If a robot masters folding a kitchen towel, we would also expect it to master folding a beach towel. However, existing works for policy learning that rely on data set augmentations are still limited in achieving this level of generalization. Our insight is to add equivariance to both the visual object representation and policy architecture. We propose EquivAct which utilizes SIM(3)-equivariant network structures that guarantee generalization across all possible object translations, 3D rotations, and scales by construction. Training of EquivAct is done in two phases. We first pre-train a SIM(3)-equivariant visual representation on simulated scene point clouds. Then, we learn a SIM(3)-equivariant visuomotor policy on top of the pre-trained visual representation using a small amount of source task demonstrations. We demonstrate that after training, the learned policy directly transfers to objects that substantially differ in scale, position and orientation from the source demonstrations. In simulation, we evaluate our method in three manipulation tasks involving deformable and articulated objects thereby going beyond the typical rigid object manipulation tasks that prior works considered. We show that our method outperforms prior works that do not use equivariant architectures or do not use our contrastive pre-training procedure. We also show quantitative and qualitative experiments on three real robot tasks, where the robot watches twenty demonstrations of a tabletop task and transfers zero-shot to a mobile manipulation task in a much larger setup. Project website: https://equivact.github.io

TidyBot: Personalized Robot Assistance with Large Language Models

For a robot to personalize physical assistance effectively, it must learn user preferences that can be generally reapplied to future scenarios. In this work, we investigate personalization of household cleanup with robots that can tidy up rooms by picking up objects and putting them away. A key challenge is determining the proper place to put each object, as people's preferences can vary greatly depending on personal taste or cultural background. For instance, one person may prefer storing shirts in the drawer, while another may prefer them on the shelf. We aim to build systems that can learn such preferences from just a handful of examples via prior interactions with a particular person. We show that robots can combine language-based planning and perception with the few-shot summarization capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to infer generalized user preferences that are broadly applicable to future interactions. This approach enables fast adaptation and achieves 91.2% accuracy on unseen objects in our benchmark dataset. We also demonstrate our approach on a real-world mobile manipulator called TidyBot, which successfully puts away 85.0% of objects in real-world test scenarios.

Learning Tool Morphology for Contact-Rich Manipulation Tasks with Differentiable Simulation

When humans perform contact-rich manipulation tasks, customized tools are often necessary and play an important role in simplifying the task. For instance, in our daily life, we use various utensils for handling food, such as knives, forks and spoons. Similarly, customized tools for robots may enable them to more easily perform a variety of tasks. Here, we present an end-to-end framework to automatically learn tool morphology for contact-rich manipulation tasks by leveraging differentiable physics simulators. Previous work approached this problem by introducing manually constructed priors that required detailed specification of object 3D model, grasp pose and task description to facilitate the search or optimization. In our approach, we instead only need to define the objective with respect to the task performance and enable learning a robust morphology by randomizing the task variations. The optimization is made tractable by casting this as a continual learning problem. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our method for designing new tools in several scenarios such as winding ropes, flipping a box and pushing peas onto a scoop in simulation. We also validate that the shapes discovered by our method help real robots succeed in these scenarios.

Task-Driven In-Hand Manipulation of Unknown Objects with Tactile Sensing

Manipulation of objects in-hand without an object model is a foundational skill for many tasks in unstructured environments. In many cases, vision-only approaches may not be feasible; for example, due to occlusion in cluttered spaces. In this paper, we introduce a method to reorient unknown objects by incrementally building a probabilistic estimate of the object shape and pose during task-driven manipulation. Our method leverages Bayesian optimization to strategically trade-off exploration of the global object shape with efficient task completion. We demonstrate our approach on a Tactile-Enabled Roller Grasper, a gripper that rolls objects in hand while continuously collecting tactile data. We evaluate our method in simulation on a set of randomly generated objects and find that our method reliably reorients objects while significantly reducing the exploration time needed to do so. On the Roller Grasper hardware, we show successful qualitative reconstruction of the object model. In summary, this work (1) presents a system capable of simultaneously learning unknown 3D object shape and pose using tactile sensing; and (2) demonstrates that task-driven exploration results in more efficient object manipulation than the common paradigm of complete object exploration before task-completion.

Rethinking Optimization with Differentiable Simulation from a Global Perspective

Differentiable simulation is a promising toolkit for fast gradient-based policy optimization and system identification. However, existing approaches to differentiable simulation have largely tackled scenarios where obtaining smooth gradients has been relatively easy, such as systems with mostly smooth dynamics. In this work, we study the challenges that differentiable simulation presents when it is not feasible to expect that a single descent reaches a global optimum, which is often a problem in contact-rich scenarios. We analyze the optimization landscapes of diverse scenarios that contain both rigid bodies and deformable objects. In dynamic environments with highly deformable objects and fluids, differentiable simulators produce rugged landscapes with nonetheless useful gradients in some parts of the space. We propose a method that combines Bayesian optimization with semi-local 'leaps' to obtain a global search method that can use gradients effectively, while also maintaining robust performance in regions with noisy gradients. We show that our approach outperforms several gradient-based and gradient-free baselines on an extensive set of experiments in simulation, and also validate the method using experiments with a real robot and deformables. Videos and supplementary materials are available at https://tinyurl.com/globdiff

DiffCloud: Real-to-Sim from Point Clouds with Differentiable Simulation and Rendering of Deformable Objects

Research in manipulation of deformable objects is typically conducted on a limited range of scenarios, because handling each scenario on hardware takes significant effort. Realistic simulators with support for various types of deformations and interactions have the potential to speed up experimentation with novel tasks and algorithms. However, for highly deformable objects it is challenging to align the output of a simulator with the behavior of real objects. Manual tuning is not intuitive, hence automated methods are needed. We view this alignment problem as a joint perception-inference challenge and demonstrate how to use recent neural network architectures to successfully perform simulation parameter inference from real point clouds. We analyze the performance of various architectures, comparing their data and training requirements. Furthermore, we propose to leverage differentiable point cloud sampling and differentiable simulation to significantly reduce the time to achieve the alignment. We employ an efficient way to propagate gradients from point clouds to simulated meshes and further through to the physical simulation parameters, such as mass and stiffness. Experiments with highly deformable objects show that our method can achieve comparable or better alignment with real object behavior, while reducing the time needed to achieve this by more than an order of magnitude. Videos and supplementary material are available at https://tinyurl.com/diffcloud.

A Bayesian Treatment of Real-to-Sim for Deformable Object Manipulation

Deformable object manipulation remains a challenging task in robotics research. Conventional techniques for parameter inference and state estimation typically rely on a precise definition of the state space and its dynamics. While this is appropriate for rigid objects and robot states, it is challenging to define the state space of a deformable object and how it evolves in time. In this work, we pose the problem of inferring physical parameters of deformable objects as a probabilistic inference task defined with a simulator. We propose a novel methodology for extracting state information from image sequences via a technique to represent the state of a deformable object as a distribution embedding. This allows to incorporate noisy state observations directly into modern Bayesian simulation-based inference tools in a principled manner. Our experiments confirm that we can estimate posterior distributions of physical properties, such as elasticity, friction and scale of highly deformable objects, such as cloth and ropes. Overall, our method addresses the real-to-sim problem probabilistically and helps to better represent the evolution of the state of deformable objects.

Learning Periodic Tasks from Human Demonstrations

We develop a method for learning periodic tasks from visual demonstrations. The core idea is to leverage periodicity in the policy structure to model periodic aspects of the tasks. We use active learning to optimize parameters of rhythmic dynamic movement primitives (rDMPs) and propose an objective to maximize the similarity between the motion of objects manipulated by the robot and the desired motion in human video demonstrations. We consider tasks with deformable objects and granular matter whose state is challenging to represent and track: wiping surfaces with a cloth, winding cables/wires, stirring granular matter with a spoon. Our method does not require tracking markers or manual annotations. The initial training data consists of 10-minute videos of random unpaired interactions with objects by the robot and human. We use these for unsupervised learning of a keypoint model to get task-agnostic visual correspondences. Then, we use Bayesian optimization to optimize rDMPs from a single human video demonstration within few robot trials. We present simulation and hardware experiments to validate our approach.