Good practices for evaluation of synthesized speech

This document is provided as a guideline for reviewers of papers about speech synthesis. We outline some best practices and common pitfalls for papers about speech synthesis, with a particular focus on evaluation. We also recommend that reviewers check the guidelines for authors written in the paper kit and consider those as reviewing criteria as well. This is intended to be a living document, and it will be updated as we receive comments and feedback from readers. We note that this document is meant to provide guidance only, and that reviewers should ultimately use their own discretion when evaluating papers.

Towards An Integrated Approach for Expressive Piano Performance Synthesis from Music Scores

This paper presents an integrated system that transforms symbolic music scores into expressive piano performance audio. By combining a Transformer-based Expressive Performance Rendering (EPR) model with a fine-tuned neural MIDI synthesiser, our approach directly generates expressive audio performances from score inputs. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first system to offer a streamlined method for converting score MIDI files lacking expression control into rich, expressive piano performances. We conducted experiments using subsets of the ATEPP dataset, evaluating the system with both objective metrics and subjective listening tests. Our system not only accurately reconstructs human-like expressiveness, but also captures the acoustic ambience of environments such as concert halls and recording studios. Additionally, the proposed system demonstrates its ability to achieve musical expressiveness while ensuring good audio quality in its outputs.

MOS-Bench: Benchmarking Generalization Abilities of Subjective Speech Quality Assessment Models

Subjective speech quality assessment (SSQA) is critical for evaluating speech samples as perceived by human listeners. While model-based SSQA has enjoyed great success thanks to the development of deep neural networks (DNNs), generalization remains a key challenge, especially for unseen, out-of-domain data. To benchmark the generalization abilities of SSQA models, we present MOS-Bench, a diverse collection of datasets. In addition, we also introduce SHEET, an open-source toolkit containing complete recipes to conduct SSQA experiments. We provided benchmark results for MOS-Bench, and we also explored multi-dataset training to enhance generalization. Additionally, we proposed a new performance metric, best score difference/ratio, and used latent space visualizations to explain model behavior, offering valuable insights for future research.

The VoiceMOS Challenge 2024: Beyond Speech Quality Prediction

We present the third edition of the VoiceMOS Challenge, a scientific initiative designed to advance research into automatic prediction of human speech ratings. There were three tracks. The first track was on predicting the quality of ``zoomed-in'' high-quality samples from speech synthesis systems. The second track was to predict ratings of samples from singing voice synthesis and voice conversion with a large variety of systems, listeners, and languages. The third track was semi-supervised quality prediction for noisy, clean, and enhanced speech, where a very small amount of labeled training data was provided. Among the eight teams from both academia and industry, we found that many were able to outperform the baseline systems. Successful techniques included retrieval-based methods and the use of non-self-supervised representations like spectrograms and pitch histograms. These results showed that the challenge has advanced the field of subjective speech rating prediction.

Spoofing-Aware Speaker Verification Robust Against Domain and Channel Mismatches

In real-world applications, it is challenging to build a speaker verification system that is simultaneously robust against common threats, including spoofing attacks, channel mismatch, and domain mismatch. Traditional automatic speaker verification (ASV) systems often tackle these issues separately, leading to suboptimal performance when faced with simultaneous challenges. In this paper, we propose an integrated framework that incorporates pair-wise learning and spoofing attack simulation into the meta-learning paradigm to enhance robustness against these multifaceted threats. This novel approach employs an asymmetric dual-path model and a multi-task learning strategy to handle ASV, anti-spoofing, and spoofing-aware ASV tasks concurrently. A new testing dataset, CNComplex, is introduced to evaluate system performance under these combined threats. Experimental results demonstrate that our integrated model significantly improves performance over traditional ASV systems across various scenarios, showcasing its potential for real-world deployment. Additionally, the proposed framework's ability to generalize across different conditions highlights its robustness and reliability, making it a promising solution for practical ASV applications.

An Initial Investigation of Language Adaptation for TTS Systems under Low-resource Scenarios

Self-supervised learning (SSL) representations from massively multilingual models offer a promising solution for low-resource language speech tasks. Despite advancements, language adaptation in TTS systems remains an open problem. This paper explores the language adaptation capability of ZMM-TTS, a recent SSL-based multilingual TTS system proposed in our previous work. We conducted experiments on 12 languages using limited data with various fine-tuning configurations. We demonstrate that the similarity in phonetics between the pre-training and target languages, as well as the language category, affects the target language's adaptation performance. Additionally, we find that the fine-tuning dataset size and number of speakers influence adaptability. Surprisingly, we also observed that using paired data for fine-tuning is not always optimal compared to audio-only data. Beyond speech intelligibility, our analysis covers speaker similarity, language identification, and predicted MOS.

Generating Speakers by Prompting Listener Impressions for Pre-trained Multi-Speaker Text-to-Speech Systems

This paper proposes a speech synthesis system that allows users to specify and control the acoustic characteristics of a speaker by means of prompts describing the speaker's traits of synthesized speech. Unlike previous approaches, our method utilizes listener impressions to construct prompts, which are easier to collect and align more naturally with everyday descriptions of speaker traits. We adopt the Low-rank Adaptation (LoRA) technique to swiftly tailor a pre-trained language model to our needs, facilitating the extraction of speaker-related traits from the prompt text. Besides, different from other prompt-driven text-to-speech (TTS) systems, we separate the prompt-to-speaker module from the multi-speaker TTS system, enhancing system flexibility and compatibility with various pre-trained multi-speaker TTS systems. Moreover, for the prompt-to-speaker characteristic module, we also compared the discriminative method and flow-matching based generative method and we found that combining both methods can help the system simultaneously capture speaker-related information from prompts better and generate speech with higher fidelity.

Spoof Diarization: "What Spoofed When" in Partially Spoofed Audio

This paper defines Spoof Diarization as a novel task in the Partial Spoof (PS) scenario. It aims to determine what spoofed when, which includes not only locating spoof regions but also clustering them according to different spoofing methods. As a pioneering study in spoof diarization, we focus on defining the task, establishing evaluation metrics, and proposing a benchmark model, namely the Countermeasure-Condition Clustering (3C) model. Utilizing this model, we first explore how to effectively train countermeasures to support spoof diarization using three labeling schemes. We then utilize spoof localization predictions to enhance the diarization performance. This first study reveals the high complexity of the task, even in restricted scenarios where only a single speaker per audio file and an oracle number of spoofing methods are considered. Our code is available at https://github.com/nii-yamagishilab/PartialSpoof.

Uncertainty as a Predictor: Leveraging Self-Supervised Learning for Zero-Shot MOS Prediction

Predicting audio quality in voice synthesis and conversion systems is a critical yet challenging task, especially when traditional methods like Mean Opinion Scores (MOS) are cumbersome to collect at scale. This paper addresses the gap in efficient audio quality prediction, especially in low-resource settings where extensive MOS data from large-scale listening tests may be unavailable. We demonstrate that uncertainty measures derived from out-of-the-box pretrained self-supervised learning (SSL) models, such as wav2vec, correlate with MOS scores. These findings are based on data from the 2022 and 2023 VoiceMOS challenges. We explore the extent of this correlation across different models and language contexts, revealing insights into how inherent uncertainties in SSL models can serve as effective proxies for audio quality assessment. In particular, we show that the contrastive wav2vec models are the most performant in all settings.

ZMM-TTS: Zero-shot Multilingual and Multispeaker Speech Synthesis Conditioned on Self-supervised Discrete Speech Representations

Neural text-to-speech (TTS) has achieved human-like synthetic speech for single-speaker, single-language synthesis. Multilingual TTS systems are limited to resource-rich languages due to the lack of large paired text and studio-quality audio data. In most cases, TTS systems are built using a single speaker's voice. However, there is growing interest in developing systems that can synthesize voices for new speakers using only a few seconds of their speech. This paper presents ZMM-TTS, a multilingual and multispeaker framework utilizing quantized latent speech representations from a large-scale, pre-trained, self-supervised model. Our paper is the first to incorporate the representations from text-based and speech-based self-supervised learning models into multilingual speech synthesis tasks. We conducted comprehensive subjective and objective evaluations through a series of experiments. Our model has been proven effective in terms of speech naturalness and similarity for both seen and unseen speakers in six high-resource languages. We also tested the efficiency of our method on two hypothetical low-resource languages. The results are promising, indicating that our proposed approach can synthesize audio that is intelligible and has a high degree of similarity to the target speaker's voice, even without any training data for the new, unseen language.