This document is provided as a guideline for reviewers of papers about speech synthesis. We outline some best practices and common pitfalls for papers about speech synthesis, with a particular focus on evaluation. We also recommend that reviewers check the guidelines for authors written in the paper kit and consider those as reviewing criteria as well. This is intended to be a living document, and it will be updated as we receive comments and feedback from readers. We note that this document is meant to provide guidance only, and that reviewers should ultimately use their own discretion when evaluating papers.