Results of the 2023 CommonRoad Motion Planning Competition for Autonomous Vehicles

In recent years, different approaches for motion planning of autonomous vehicles have been proposed that can handle complex traffic situations. However, these approaches are rarely compared on the same set of benchmarks. To address this issue, we present the results of a large-scale motion planning competition for autonomous vehicles based on the CommonRoad benchmark suite. The benchmark scenarios contain highway and urban environments featuring various types of traffic participants, such as passengers, cars, buses, etc. The solutions are evaluated considering efficiency, safety, comfort, and compliance with a selection of traffic rules. This report summarizes the main results of the competition.

DualAD: Dual-Layer Planning for Reasoning in Autonomous Driving

We present a novel autonomous driving framework, DualAD, designed to imitate human reasoning during driving. DualAD comprises two layers: a rule-based motion planner at the bottom layer that handles routine driving tasks requiring minimal reasoning, and an upper layer featuring a rule-based text encoder that converts driving scenarios from absolute states into text description. This text is then processed by a large language model (LLM) to make driving decisions. The upper layer intervenes in the bottom layer's decisions when potential danger is detected, mimicking human reasoning in critical situations. Closed-loop experiments demonstrate that DualAD, using a zero-shot pre-trained model, significantly outperforms rule-based motion planners that lack reasoning abilities. Our experiments also highlight the effectiveness of the text encoder, which considerably enhances the model's scenario understanding. Additionally, the integrated DualAD model improves with stronger LLMs, indicating the framework's potential for further enhancement. We make code and benchmarks publicly available.

Three-Dimensional Vehicle Dynamics State Estimation for High-Speed Race Cars under varying Signal Quality

This work aims to present a three-dimensional vehicle dynamics state estimation under varying signal quality. Few researchers have investigated the impact of three-dimensional road geometries on the state estimation and, thus, neglect road inclination and banking. Especially considering high velocities and accelerations, the literature does not address these effects. Therefore, we compare two- and three-dimensional state estimation schemes to outline the impact of road geometries. We use an Extended Kalman Filter with a point-mass motion model and extend it by an additional formulation of reference angles. Furthermore, virtual velocity measurements significantly improve the estimation of road angles and the vehicle's side slip angle. We highlight the importance of steady estimations for vehicle motion control algorithms and demonstrate the challenges of degraded signal quality and Global Navigation Satellite System dropouts. The proposed adaptive covariance facilitates a smooth estimation and enables stable controller behavior. The developed state estimation has been deployed on a high-speed autonomous race car at various racetracks. Our findings indicate that our approach outperforms state-of-the-art vehicle dynamics state estimators and an industry-grade Inertial Navigation System. Further studies are needed to investigate the performance under varying track conditions and on other vehicle types.

A Survey on Small-Scale Testbeds for Connected and Automated Vehicles and Robot Swarms

Connected and automated vehicles and robot swarms hold transformative potential for enhancing safety, efficiency, and sustainability in the transportation and manufacturing sectors. Extensive testing and validation of these technologies is crucial for their deployment in the real world. While simulations are essential for initial testing, they often have limitations in capturing the complex dynamics of real-world interactions. This limitation underscores the importance of small-scale testbeds. These testbeds provide a realistic, cost-effective, and controlled environment for testing and validating algorithms, acting as an essential intermediary between simulation and full-scale experiments. This work serves to facilitate researchers' efforts in identifying existing small-scale testbeds suitable for their experiments and provide insights for those who want to build their own. In addition, it delivers a comprehensive survey of the current landscape of these testbeds. We derive 62 characteristics of testbeds based on the well-known sense-plan-act paradigm and offer an online table comparing 22 small-scale testbeds based on these characteristics. The online table is hosted on our designated public webpage www.cpm-remote.de/testbeds, and we invite testbed creators and developers to contribute to it. We closely examine nine testbeds in this paper, demonstrating how the derived characteristics can be used to present testbeds. Furthermore, we discuss three ongoing challenges concerning small-scale testbeds that we identified, i.e., small-scale to full-scale transition, sustainability, and power and resource management.

ESP: Extro-Spective Prediction for Long-term Behavior Reasoning in Emergency Scenarios

Emergent-scene safety is the key milestone for fully autonomous driving, and reliable on-time prediction is essential to maintain safety in emergency scenarios. However, these emergency scenarios are long-tailed and hard to collect, which restricts the system from getting reliable predictions. In this paper, we build a new dataset, which aims at the long-term prediction with the inconspicuous state variation in history for the emergency event, named the Extro-Spective Prediction (ESP) problem. Based on the proposed dataset, a flexible feature encoder for ESP is introduced to various prediction methods as a seamless plug-in, and its consistent performance improvement underscores its efficacy. Furthermore, a new metric named clamped temporal error (CTE) is proposed to give a more comprehensive evaluation of prediction performance, especially in time-sensitive emergency events of subseconds. Interestingly, as our ESP features can be described in human-readable language naturally, the application of integrating into ChatGPT also shows huge potential. The ESP-dataset and all benchmarks are released at https://dingrui-wang.github.io/ESP-Dataset/.

Accelerating Autonomy: Insights from Pro Racers in the Era of Autonomous Racing - An Expert Interview Study

This research aims to investigate professional racing drivers' expertise to develop an understanding of their cognitive and adaptive skills to create new autonomy algorithms. An expert interview study was conducted with 11 professional race drivers, data analysts, and racing instructors from across prominent racing leagues. The interviews were conducted using an exploratory, non-standardized expert interview format guided by a set of prepared questions. The study investigates drivers' exploration strategies to reach their vehicle limits and contrasts them with the capabilities of state-of-the-art autonomous racing software stacks. Participants were questioned about the techniques and skills they have developed to quickly approach and maneuver at the vehicle limit, ultimately minimizing lap times. The analysis of the interviews was grounded in Mayring's qualitative content analysis framework, which facilitated the organization of the data into multiple categories and subcategories. Our findings create insights into human behavior regarding reaching a vehicle's limit and minimizing lap times. We conclude from the findings the development of new autonomy software modules that allow for more adaptive vehicle behavior. By emphasizing the distinct nuances between manual and autonomous driving techniques, the paper encourages further investigation into human drivers' strategies to maximize their vehicles' capabilities.

A new Taxonomy for Automated Driving: Structuring Applications based on their Operational Design Domain, Level of Automation and Automation Readiness

The aim of this paper is to investigate the relationship between operational design domains (ODD), automated driving SAE Levels, and Technology Readiness Level (TRL). The first highly automated vehicles, like robotaxis, are in commercial use, and the first vehicles with highway pilot systems have been delivered to private customers. It has emerged as a crucial issue that these automated driving systems differ significantly in their ODD and in their technical maturity. Consequently, any approach to compare these systems is difficult and requires a deep dive into defined ODDs, specifications, and technologies used. Therefore, this paper challenges current state-of-the-art taxonomies and develops a new and integrated taxonomy that can structure automated vehicle systems more efficiently. We use the well-known SAE Levels 0-5 as the "level of responsibility", and link and describe the ODD at an intermediate level of abstraction. Finally, a new maturity model is explicitly proposed to improve the comparability of automated vehicles and driving functions. This method is then used to analyze today's existing automated vehicle applications, which are structured into the new taxonomy and rated by the new maturity levels. Our results indicate that this new taxonomy and maturity level model will help to differentiate automated vehicle systems in discussions more clearly and to discover white fields more systematically and upfront, e.g. for research but also for regulatory purposes.

A Containerized Microservice Architecture for a ROS 2 Autonomous Driving Software: An End-to-End Latency Evaluation

The automotive industry is transitioning from traditional ECU-based systems to software-defined vehicles. A central role of this revolution is played by containers, lightweight virtualization technologies that enable the flexible consolidation of complex software applications on a common hardware platform. Despite their widespread adoption, the impact of containerization on fundamental real-time metrics such as end-to-end latency, communication jitter, as well as memory and CPU utilization has remained virtually unexplored. This paper presents a microservice architecture for a real-world autonomous driving application where containers isolate each service. Our comprehensive evaluation shows the benefits in terms of end-to-end latency of such a solution even over standard bare-Linux deployments. Specifically, in the case of the presented microservice architecture, the mean end-to-end latency can be improved by 5-8 %. Also, the maximum latencies were significantly reduced using container deployment.

FlexMap Fusion: Georeferencing and Automated Conflation of HD Maps with OpenStreetMap

Today's software stacks for autonomous vehicles rely on HD maps to enable sufficient localization, accurate path planning, and reliable motion prediction. Recent developments have resulted in pipelines for the automated generation of HD maps to reduce manual efforts for creating and updating these HD maps. We present FlexMap Fusion, a methodology to automatically update and enhance existing HD vector maps using OpenStreetMap. Our approach is designed to enable the use of HD maps created from LiDAR and camera data within Autoware. The pipeline provides different functionalities: It provides the possibility to georeference both the point cloud map and the vector map using an RTK-corrected GNSS signal. Moreover, missing semantic attributes can be conflated from OpenStreetMap into the vector map. Differences between the HD map and OpenStreetMap are visualized for manual refinement by the user. In general, our findings indicate that our approach leads to reduced human labor during HD map generation, increases the scalability of the mapping pipeline, and improves the completeness and usability of the maps. The methodological choices may have resulted in limitations that arise especially at complex street structures, e.g., traffic islands. Therefore, more research is necessary to create efficient preprocessing algorithms and advancements in the dynamic adjustment of matching parameters. In order to build upon our work, our source code is available at https://github.com/TUMFTM/FlexMap_Fusion.

Investigating Driving Interactions: A Robust Multi-Agent Simulation Framework for Autonomous Vehicles

Current validation methods often rely on recorded data and basic functional checks, which may not be sufficient to encompass the scenarios an autonomous vehicle might encounter. In addition, there is a growing need for complex scenarios with changing vehicle interactions for comprehensive validation. This work introduces a novel synchronous multi-agent simulation framework for autonomous vehicles in interactive scenarios. Our approach creates an interactive scenario and incorporates publicly available edge-case scenarios wherein simulated vehicles are replaced by agents navigating to predefined destinations. We provide a platform that enables the integration of different autonomous driving planning methodologies and includes a set of evaluation metrics to assess autonomous driving behavior. Our study explores different planning setups and adjusts simulation complexity to test the framework's adaptability and performance. Results highlight the critical role of simulating vehicle interactions to enhance autonomous driving systems. Our setup offers unique insights for developing advanced algorithms for complex driving tasks to accelerate future investigations and developments in this field. The multi-agent simulation framework is available as open-source software: https://github.com/TUM-AVS/Frenetix-Motion-Planner