Beyond Complete Shapes: A quantitative Evaluation of 3D Shape Matching Algorithms

Finding correspondences between 3D shapes is an important and long-standing problem in computer vision, graphics and beyond. While approaches based on machine learning dominate modern 3D shape matching, almost all existing (learning-based) methods require that at least one of the involved shapes is complete. In contrast, the most challenging and arguably most practically relevant setting of matching partially observed shapes, is currently underexplored. One important factor is that existing datasets contain only a small number of shapes (typically below 100), which are unable to serve data-hungry machine learning approaches, particularly in the unsupervised regime. In addition, the type of partiality present in existing datasets is often artificial and far from realistic. To address these limitations and to encourage research on these relevant settings, we provide a generic and flexible framework for the procedural generation of challenging partial shape matching scenarios. Our framework allows for a virtually infinite generation of partial shape matching instances from a finite set of shapes with complete geometry. Further, we manually create cross-dataset correspondences between seven existing (complete geometry) shape matching datasets, leading to a total of 2543 shapes. Based on this, we propose several challenging partial benchmark settings, for which we evaluate respective state-of-the-art methods as baselines.

Synchronous Diffusion for Unsupervised Smooth Non-Rigid 3D Shape Matching

Most recent unsupervised non-rigid 3D shape matching methods are based on the functional map framework due to its efficiency and superior performance. Nevertheless, respective methods struggle to obtain spatially smooth pointwise correspondences due to the lack of proper regularisation. In this work, inspired by the success of message passing on graphs, we propose a synchronous diffusion process which we use as regularisation to achieve smoothness in non-rigid 3D shape matching problems. The intuition of synchronous diffusion is that diffusing the same input function on two different shapes results in consistent outputs. Using different challenging datasets, we demonstrate that our novel regularisation can substantially improve the state-of-the-art in shape matching, especially in the presence of topological noise.

Unlocking the Potential of Operations Research for Multi-Graph Matching

We consider the incomplete multi-graph matching problem, which is a generalization of the NP-hard quadratic assignment problem for matching multiple finite sets. Multi-graph matching plays a central role in computer vision, e.g., for matching images or shapes, so that a number of dedicated optimization techniques have been proposed. While the closely related NP-hard multi-dimensional assignment problem (MDAP) has been studied for decades in the operations research community, it only considers complete matchings and has a different cost structure. We bridge this gap and transfer well-known approximation algorithms for the MDAP to incomplete multi-graph matching. To this end, we revisit respective algorithms, adapt them to incomplete multi-graph matching, and propose their extended and parallelized versions. Our experimental validation shows that our new method substantially outperforms the previous state of the art in terms of objective and runtime. Our algorithm matches, for example, 29 images with more than 500 keypoints each in less than two minutes, whereas the fastest considered competitor requires at least half an hour while producing far worse results.

$C^2M^3$: Cycle-Consistent Multi-Model Merging

In this paper, we present a novel data-free method for merging neural networks in weight space. Differently from most existing works, our method optimizes for the permutations of network neurons globally across all layers. This allows us to enforce cycle consistency of the permutations when merging $N \geq 3$ models, allowing circular compositions of permutations to be computed without accumulating error along the path. We qualitatively and quantitatively motivate the need for such a constraint, showing its benefits when merging sets of models in scenarios spanning varying architectures and datasets. We finally show that, when coupled with activation renormalization, our approach yields the best results in the task.

Partial-to-Partial Shape Matching with Geometric Consistency

Finding correspondences between 3D shapes is an important and long-standing problem in computer vision, graphics and beyond. A prominent challenge are partial-to-partial shape matching settings, which occur when the shapes to match are only observed incompletely (e.g. from 3D scanning). Although partial-to-partial matching is a highly relevant setting in practice, it is rarely explored. Our work bridges the gap between existing (rather artificial) 3D full shape matching and partial-to-partial real-world settings by exploiting geometric consistency as a strong constraint. We demonstrate that it is indeed possible to solve this challenging problem in a variety of settings. For the first time, we achieve geometric consistency for partial-to-partial matching, which is realized by a novel integer non-linear program formalism building on triangle product spaces, along with a new pruning algorithm based on linear integer programming. Further, we generate a new inter-class dataset for partial-to-partial shape-matching. We show that our method outperforms current SOTA methods on both an established intra-class dataset and our novel inter-class dataset.

Spectral Meets Spatial: Harmonising 3D Shape Matching and Interpolation

Although 3D shape matching and interpolation are highly interrelated, they are often studied separately and applied sequentially to relate different 3D shapes, thus resulting in sub-optimal performance. In this work we present a unified framework to predict both point-wise correspondences and shape interpolation between 3D shapes. To this end, we combine the deep functional map framework with classical surface deformation models to map shapes in both spectral and spatial domains. On the one hand, by incorporating spatial maps, our method obtains more accurate and smooth point-wise correspondences compared to previous functional map methods for shape matching. On the other hand, by introducing spectral maps, our method gets rid of commonly used but computationally expensive geodesic distance constraints that are only valid for near-isometric shape deformations. Furthermore, we propose a novel test-time adaptation scheme to capture both pose-dominant and shape-dominant deformations. Using different challenging datasets, we demonstrate that our method outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods for both shape matching and interpolation, even compared to supervised approaches.

Non-Negative Spherical Relaxations for Universe-Free Multi-Matching and Clustering

We propose a novel non-negative spherical relaxation for optimization problems over binary matrices with injectivity constraints, which in particular has applications in multi-matching and clustering. We relax respective binary matrix constraints to the (high-dimensional) non-negative sphere. To optimize our relaxed problem, we use a conditional power iteration method to iteratively improve the objective function, while at same time sweeping over a continuous scalar parameter that is (indirectly) related to the universe size (or number of clusters). Opposed to existing procedures that require to fix the integer universe size before optimization, our method automatically adjusts the analogous continuous parameter. Furthermore, while our approach shares similarities with spectral multi-matching and spectral clustering, our formulation has the strong advantage that we do not rely on additional post-processing procedures to obtain binary results. Our method shows compelling results in various multi-matching and clustering settings, even when compared to methods that use the ground truth universe size (or number of clusters).

Revisiting Map Relations for Unsupervised Non-Rigid Shape Matching

We propose a novel unsupervised learning approach for non-rigid 3D shape matching. Our approach improves upon recent state-of-the art deep functional map methods and can be applied to a broad range of different challenging scenarios. Previous deep functional map methods mainly focus on feature extraction and aim exclusively at obtaining more expressive features for functional map computation. However, the importance of the functional map computation itself is often neglected and the relationship between the functional map and point-wise map is underexplored. In this paper, we systematically investigate the coupling relationship between the functional map from the functional map solver and the point-wise map based on feature similarity. To this end, we propose a self-adaptive functional map solver to adjust the functional map regularisation for different shape matching scenarios, together with a vertex-wise contrastive loss to obtain more discriminative features. Using different challenging datasets (including non-isometry, topological noise and partiality), we demonstrate that our method substantially outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods.

Fast Discrete Optimisation for Geometrically Consistent 3D Shape Matching

In this work we propose to combine the advantages of learning-based and combinatorial formalisms for 3D shape matching. While learning-based shape matching solutions lead to state-of-the-art matching performance, they do not ensure geometric consistency, so that obtained matchings are locally unsmooth. On the contrary, axiomatic methods allow to take geometric consistency into account by explicitly constraining the space of valid matchings. However, existing axiomatic formalisms are impractical since they do not scale to practically relevant problem sizes, or they require user input for the initialisation of non-convex optimisation problems. In this work we aim to close this gap by proposing a novel combinatorial solver that combines a unique set of favourable properties: our approach is (i) initialisation free, (ii) massively parallelisable powered by a quasi-Newton method, (iii) provides optimality gaps, and (iv) delivers decreased runtime and globally optimal results for many instances.

Geometrically Consistent Partial Shape Matching

Finding correspondences between 3D shapes is a crucial problem in computer vision and graphics, which is for example relevant for tasks like shape interpolation, pose transfer, or texture transfer. An often neglected but essential property of matchings is geometric consistency, which means that neighboring triangles in one shape are consistently matched to neighboring triangles in the other shape. Moreover, while in practice one often has only access to partial observations of a 3D shape (e.g. due to occlusion, or scanning artifacts), there do not exist any methods that directly address geometrically consistent partial shape matching. In this work we fill this gap by proposing to integrate state-of-the-art deep shape features into a novel integer linear programming partial shape matching formulation. Our optimization yields a globally optimal solution on low resolution shapes, which we then refine using a coarse-to-fine scheme. We show that our method can find more reliable results on partial shapes in comparison to existing geometrically consistent algorithms (for which one first has to fill missing parts with a dummy geometry). Moreover, our matchings are substantially smoother than learning-based state-of-the-art shape matching methods.