Efficient Supernet Training with Orthogonal Softmax for Scalable ASR Model Compression

ASR systems are deployed across diverse environments, each with specific hardware constraints. We use supernet training to jointly train multiple encoders of varying sizes, enabling dynamic model size adjustment to fit hardware constraints without redundant training. Moreover, we introduce a novel method called OrthoSoftmax, which applies multiple orthogonal softmax functions to efficiently identify optimal subnets within the supernet, avoiding resource-intensive search. This approach also enables more flexible and precise subnet selection by allowing selection based on various criteria and levels of granularity. Our results with CTC on Librispeech and TED-LIUM-v2 show that FLOPs-aware component-wise selection achieves the best overall performance. With the same number of training updates from one single job, WERs for all model sizes are comparable to or slightly better than those of individually trained models. Furthermore, we analyze patterns in the selected components and reveal interesting insights.

Classification Error Bound for Low Bayes Error Conditions in Machine Learning

In statistical classification and machine learning, classification error is an important performance measure, which is minimized by the Bayes decision rule. In practice, the unknown true distribution is usually replaced with a model distribution estimated from the training data in the Bayes decision rule. This substitution introduces a mismatch between the Bayes error and the model-based classification error. In this work, we apply classification error bounds to study the relationship between the error mismatch and the Kullback-Leibler divergence in machine learning. Motivated by recent observations of low model-based classification errors in many machine learning tasks, bounding the Bayes error to be lower, we propose a linear approximation of the classification error bound for low Bayes error conditions. Then, the bound for class priors are discussed. Moreover, we extend the classification error bound for sequences. Using automatic speech recognition as a representative example of machine learning applications, this work analytically discusses the correlations among different performance measures with extended bounds, including cross-entropy loss, language model perplexity, and word error rate.

Right Label Context in End-to-End Training of Time-Synchronous ASR Models

Current time-synchronous sequence-to-sequence automatic speech recognition (ASR) models are trained by using sequence level cross-entropy that sums over all alignments. Due to the discriminative formulation, incorporating the right label context into the training criterion's gradient causes normalization problems and is not mathematically well-defined. The classic hybrid neural network hidden Markov model (NN-HMM) with its inherent generative formulation enables conditioning on the right label context. However, due to the HMM state-tying the identity of the right label context is never modeled explicitly. In this work, we propose a factored loss with auxiliary left and right label contexts that sums over all alignments. We show that the inclusion of the right label context is particularly beneficial when training data resources are limited. Moreover, we also show that it is possible to build a factored hybrid HMM system by relying exclusively on the full-sum criterion. Experiments were conducted on Switchboard 300h and LibriSpeech 960h.

The Conformer Encoder May Reverse the Time Dimension

We sometimes observe monotonically decreasing cross-attention weights in our Conformer-based global attention-based encoder-decoder (AED) models. Further investigation shows that the Conformer encoder internally reverses the sequence in the time dimension. We analyze the initial behavior of the decoder cross-attention mechanism and find that it encourages the Conformer encoder self-attention to build a connection between the initial frames and all other informative frames. Furthermore, we show that, at some point in training, the self-attention module of the Conformer starts dominating the output over the preceding feed-forward module, which then only allows the reversed information to pass through. We propose several methods and ideas of how this flipping can be avoided. Additionally, we investigate a novel method to obtain label-frame-position alignments by using the gradients of the label log probabilities w.r.t. the encoder input frames.

On the Problem of Text-To-Speech Model Selection for Synthetic Data Generation in Automatic Speech Recognition

The rapid development of neural text-to-speech (TTS) systems enabled its usage in other areas of natural language processing such as automatic speech recognition (ASR) or spoken language translation (SLT). Due to the large number of different TTS architectures and their extensions, selecting which TTS systems to use for synthetic data creation is not an easy task. We use the comparison of five different TTS decoder architectures in the scope of synthetic data generation to show the impact on CTC-based speech recognition training. We compare the recognition results to computable metrics like NISQA MOS and intelligibility, finding that there are no clear relations to the ASR performance. We also observe that for data generation auto-regressive decoding performs better than non-autoregressive decoding, and propose an approach to quantify TTS generalization capabilities.

On the Effect of Purely Synthetic Training Data for Different Automatic Speech Recognition Architectures

In this work we evaluate the utility of synthetic data for training automatic speech recognition (ASR). We use the ASR training data to train a text-to-speech (TTS) system similar to FastSpeech-2. With this TTS we reproduce the original training data, training ASR systems solely on synthetic data. For ASR, we use three different architectures, attention-based encoder-decoder, hybrid deep neural network hidden Markov model and a Gaussian mixture hidden Markov model, showing the different sensitivity of the models to synthetic data generation. In order to extend previous work, we present a number of ablation studies on the effectiveness of synthetic vs. real training data for ASR. In particular we focus on how the gap between training on synthetic and real data changes by varying the speaker embedding or by scaling the model size. For the latter we show that the TTS models generalize well, even when training scores indicate overfitting.

Investigating the Effect of Label Topology and Training Criterion on ASR Performance and Alignment Quality

The ongoing research scenario for automatic speech recognition (ASR) envisions a clear division between end-to-end approaches and classic modular systems. Even though a high-level comparison between the two approaches in terms of their requirements and (dis)advantages is commonly addressed, a closer comparison under similar conditions is not readily available in the literature. In this work, we present a comparison focused on the label topology and training criterion. We compare two discriminative alignment models with hidden Markov model (HMM) and connectionist temporal classification topology, and two first-order label context ASR models utilizing factored HMM and strictly monotonic recurrent neural network transducer, respectively. We use different measurements for the evaluation of the alignment quality, and compare word error rate and real time factor of our best systems. Experiments are conducted on the LibriSpeech 960h and Switchboard 300h tasks.

On the Relevance of Phoneme Duration Variability of Synthesized Training Data for Automatic Speech Recognition

Synthetic data generated by text-to-speech (TTS) systems can be used to improve automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems in low-resource or domain mismatch tasks. It has been shown that TTS-generated outputs still do not have the same qualities as real data. In this work we focus on the temporal structure of synthetic data and its relation to ASR training. By using a novel oracle setup we show how much the degradation of synthetic data quality is influenced by duration modeling in non-autoregressive (NAR) TTS. To get reference phoneme durations we use two common alignment methods, a hidden Markov Gaussian-mixture model (HMM-GMM) aligner and a neural connectionist temporal classification (CTC) aligner. Using a simple algorithm based on random walks we shift phoneme duration distributions of the TTS system closer to real durations, resulting in an improvement of an ASR system using synthetic data in a semi-supervised setting.

Investigating the Effect of Language Models in Sequence Discriminative Training for Neural Transducers

In this work, we investigate the effect of language models (LMs) with different context lengths and label units (phoneme vs. word) used in sequence discriminative training for phoneme-based neural transducers. Both lattice-free and N-best-list approaches are examined. For lattice-free methods with phoneme-level LMs, we propose a method to approximate the context history to employ LMs with full-context dependency. This approximation can be extended to arbitrary context length and enables the usage of word-level LMs in lattice-free methods. Moreover, a systematic comparison is conducted across lattice-free and N-best-list-based methods. Experimental results on Librispeech show that using the word-level LM in training outperforms the phoneme-level LM. Besides, we find that the context size of the LM used for probability computation has a limited effect on performance. Moreover, our results reveal the pivotal importance of the hypothesis space quality in sequence discriminative training.

End-to-End Training of a Neural HMM with Label and Transition Probabilities

We investigate a novel modeling approach for end-to-end neural network training using hidden Markov models (HMM) where the transition probabilities between hidden states are modeled and learned explicitly. Most contemporary sequence-to-sequence models allow for from-scratch training by summing over all possible label segmentations in a given topology. In our approach there are explicit, learnable probabilities for transitions between segments as opposed to a blank label that implicitly encodes duration statistics. We implement a GPU-based forward-backward algorithm that enables the simultaneous training of label and transition probabilities. We investigate recognition results and additionally Viterbi alignments of our models. We find that while the transition model training does not improve recognition performance, it has a positive impact on the alignment quality. The generated alignments are shown to be viable targets in state-of-the-art Viterbi trainings.