The Role of Temporal Hierarchy in Spiking Neural Networks

Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) have the potential for rich spatio-temporal signal processing thanks to exploiting both spatial and temporal parameters. The temporal dynamics such as time constants of the synapses and neurons and delays have been recently shown to have computational benefits that help reduce the overall number of parameters required in the network and increase the accuracy of the SNNs in solving temporal tasks. Optimizing such temporal parameters, for example, through gradient descent, gives rise to a temporal architecture for different problems. As has been shown in machine learning, to reduce the cost of optimization, architectural biases can be applied, in this case in the temporal domain. Such inductive biases in temporal parameters have been found in neuroscience studies, highlighting a hierarchy of temporal structure and input representation in different layers of the cortex. Motivated by this, we propose to impose a hierarchy of temporal representation in the hidden layers of SNNs, highlighting that such an inductive bias improves their performance. We demonstrate the positive effects of temporal hierarchy in the time constants of feed-forward SNNs applied to temporal tasks (Multi-Time-Scale XOR and Keyword Spotting, with a benefit of up to 4.1% in classification accuracy). Moreover, we show that such architectural biases, i.e. hierarchy of time constants, naturally emerge when optimizing the time constants through gradient descent, initialized as homogeneous values. We further pursue this proposal in temporal convolutional SNNs, by introducing the hierarchical bias in the size and dilation of temporal kernels, giving rise to competitive results in popular temporal spike-based datasets.

DelGrad: Exact gradients in spiking networks for learning transmission delays and weights

Spiking neural networks (SNNs) inherently rely on the timing of signals for representing and processing information. Transmission delays play an important role in shaping these temporal characteristics. Recent work has demonstrated the substantial advantages of learning these delays along with synaptic weights, both in terms of accuracy and memory efficiency. However, these approaches suffer from drawbacks in terms of precision and efficiency, as they operate in discrete time and with approximate gradients, while also requiring membrane potential recordings for calculating parameter updates. To alleviate these issues, we propose an analytical approach for calculating exact loss gradients with respect to both synaptic weights and delays in an event-based fashion. The inclusion of delays emerges naturally within our proposed formalism, enriching the model's search space with a temporal dimension. Our algorithm is purely based on the timing of individual spikes and does not require access to other variables such as membrane potentials. We explicitly compare the impact on accuracy and parameter efficiency of different types of delays - axonal, dendritic and synaptic. Furthermore, while previous work on learnable delays in SNNs has been mostly confined to software simulations, we demonstrate the functionality and benefits of our approach on the BrainScaleS-2 neuromorphic platform.

DenRAM: Neuromorphic Dendritic Architecture with RRAM for Efficient Temporal Processing with Delays

An increasing number of neuroscience studies are highlighting the importance of spatial dendritic branching in pyramidal neurons in the brain for supporting non-linear computation through localized synaptic integration. In particular, dendritic branches play a key role in temporal signal processing and feature detection, using coincidence detection (CD) mechanisms, made possible by the presence of synaptic delays that align temporally disparate inputs for effective integration. Computational studies on spiking neural networks further highlight the significance of delays for CD operations, enabling spatio-temporal pattern recognition within feed-forward neural networks without the need for recurrent architectures. In this work, we present DenRAM, the first realization of a spiking neural network with analog dendritic circuits, integrated into a 130nm technology node coupled with resistive memory (RRAM) technology. DenRAM's dendritic circuits use the RRAM devices to implement both delays and synaptic weights in the network. By configuring the RRAM devices to reproduce bio-realistic timescales, and through exploiting their heterogeneity, we experimentally demonstrate DenRAM's capability to replicate synaptic delay profiles, and efficiently implement CD for spatio-temporal pattern recognition. To validate the architecture, we conduct comprehensive system-level simulations on two representative temporal benchmarks, highlighting DenRAM's resilience to analog hardware noise, and its superior accuracy compared to recurrent architectures with an equivalent number of parameters. DenRAM not only brings rich temporal processing capabilities to neuromorphic architectures, but also reduces the memory footprint of edge devices, provides high accuracy on temporal benchmarks, and represents a significant step-forward in low-power real-time signal processing technologies.

Scaling Limits of Memristor-Based Routers for Asynchronous Neuromorphic Systems

Multi-core neuromorphic systems typically use on-chip routers to transmit spikes among cores. These routers require significant memory resources and consume a large part of the overall system's energy budget. A promising alternative approach to using standard CMOS and SRAM-based routers is to exploit the features of memristive crossbar arrays and use them as programmable switch-matrices that route spikes. However, the scaling of these crossbar arrays presents physical challenges, such as `IR drop' on the metal lines due to the parasitic resistance, and leakage current accumulation on multiple active `off' memristors. While reliability challenges of this type have been extensively studied in synchronous systems for compute-in-memory matrix-vector multiplication (MVM) accelerators and storage class memory, little effort has been devoted so far to characterizing the scaling limits of memristor-based crossbar routers. In this paper, we study the challenges of memristive crossbar arrays, when used as routing channels to transmit spikes in asynchronous Spiking Neural Network (SNN) hardware. We validate our analytical findings with experimental results obtained from a 4K-ReRAM chip which demonstrate its functionality as a routing crossbar. We determine the functionality bounds on the routing due to the IR drop and leak problem, based both on experimental measurements, modeling and circuit simulations in a 22nm FDSOI technology. This work highlights the constraint of this approach and provides useful guidelines for engineering memristor properties in memristive crossbar routers for building multi-core asynchronous neuromorphic systems.

Neuromorphic analog circuits for robust on-chip always-on learning in spiking neural networks

Mixed-signal neuromorphic systems represent a promising solution for solving extreme-edge computing tasks without relying on external computing resources. Their spiking neural network circuits are optimized for processing sensory data on-line in continuous-time. However, their low precision and high variability can severely limit their performance. To address this issue and improve their robustness to inhomogeneities and noise in both their internal state variables and external input signals, we designed on-chip learning circuits with short-term analog dynamics and long-term tristate discretization mechanisms. An additional hysteretic stop-learning mechanism is included to improve stability and automatically disable weight updates when necessary, to enable continuous always-on learning. We designed a spiking neural network with these learning circuits in a prototype chip using a 180 nm CMOS technology. Simulation and silicon measurement results from the prototype chip are presented. These circuits enable the construction of large-scale spiking neural networks with online learning capabilities for real-world edge computing tasks.

Synaptic metaplasticity with multi-level memristive devices

Deep learning has made remarkable progress in various tasks, surpassing human performance in some cases. However, one drawback of neural networks is catastrophic forgetting, where a network trained on one task forgets the solution when learning a new one. To address this issue, recent works have proposed solutions based on Binarized Neural Networks (BNNs) incorporating metaplasticity. In this work, we extend this solution to quantized neural networks (QNNs) and present a memristor-based hardware solution for implementing metaplasticity during both inference and training. We propose a hardware architecture that integrates quantized weights in memristor devices programmed in an analog multi-level fashion with a digital processing unit for high-precision metaplastic storage. We validated our approach using a combined software framework and memristor based crossbar array for in-memory computing fabricated in 130 nm CMOS technology. Our experimental results show that a two-layer perceptron achieves 97% and 86% accuracy on consecutive training of MNIST and Fashion-MNIST, equal to software baseline. This result demonstrates immunity to catastrophic forgetting and the resilience to analog device imperfections of the proposed solution. Moreover, our architecture is compatible with the memristor limited endurance and has a 15x reduction in memory

Dendritic Computation through Exploiting Resistive Memory as both Delays and Weights

Biological neurons can detect complex spatio-temporal features in spiking patterns via their synapses spread across across their dendritic branches. This is achieved by modulating the efficacy of the individual synapses, and by exploiting the temporal delays of their response to input spikes, depending on their position on the dendrite. Inspired by this mechanism, we propose a neuromorphic hardware architecture equipped with multiscale dendrites, each of which has synapses with tunable weight and delay elements. Weights and delays are both implemented using Resistive Random Access Memory (RRAM). We exploit the variability in the high resistance state of RRAM to implement a distribution of delays in the millisecond range for enabling spatio-temporal detection of sensory signals. We demonstrate the validity of the approach followed with a RRAM-aware simulation of a heartbeat anomaly detection task. In particular we show that, by incorporating delays directly into the network, the network's power and memory footprint can be reduced by up to 100x compared to equivalent state-of-the-art spiking recurrent networks with no delays.

NeuroBench: Advancing Neuromorphic Computing through Collaborative, Fair and Representative Benchmarking

The field of neuromorphic computing holds great promise in terms of advancing computing efficiency and capabilities by following brain-inspired principles. However, the rich diversity of techniques employed in neuromorphic research has resulted in a lack of clear standards for benchmarking, hindering effective evaluation of the advantages and strengths of neuromorphic methods compared to traditional deep-learning-based methods. This paper presents a collaborative effort, bringing together members from academia and the industry, to define benchmarks for neuromorphic computing: NeuroBench. The goals of NeuroBench are to be a collaborative, fair, and representative benchmark suite developed by the community, for the community. In this paper, we discuss the challenges associated with benchmarking neuromorphic solutions, and outline the key features of NeuroBench. We believe that NeuroBench will be a significant step towards defining standards that can unify the goals of neuromorphic computing and drive its technological progress. Please visit neurobench.ai for the latest updates on the benchmark tasks and metrics.

Online Training of Spiking Recurrent Neural Networks with Phase-Change Memory Synapses

Spiking recurrent neural networks (RNNs) are a promising tool for solving a wide variety of complex cognitive and motor tasks, due to their rich temporal dynamics and sparse processing. However training spiking RNNs on dedicated neuromorphic hardware is still an open challenge. This is due mainly to the lack of local, hardware-friendly learning mechanisms that can solve the temporal credit assignment problem and ensure stable network dynamics, even when the weight resolution is limited. These challenges are further accentuated, if one resorts to using memristive devices for in-memory computing to resolve the von-Neumann bottleneck problem, at the expense of a substantial increase in variability in both the computation and the working memory of the spiking RNNs. To address these challenges and enable online learning in memristive neuromorphic RNNs, we present a simulation framework of differential-architecture crossbar arrays based on an accurate and comprehensive Phase-Change Memory (PCM) device model. We train a spiking RNN whose weights are emulated in the presented simulation framework, using a recently proposed e-prop learning rule. Although e-prop locally approximates the ideal synaptic updates, it is difficult to implement the updates on the memristive substrate due to substantial PCM non-idealities. We compare several widely adapted weight update schemes that primarily aim to cope with these device non-idealities and demonstrate that accumulating gradients can enable online and efficient training of spiking RNN on memristive substrates.

On-Chip Error-triggered Learning of Multi-layer Memristive Spiking Neural Networks

Recent breakthroughs in neuromorphic computing show that local forms of gradient descent learning are compatible with Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) and synaptic plasticity. Although SNNs can be scalably implemented using neuromorphic VLSI, an architecture that can learn using gradient-descent in situ is still missing. In this paper, we propose a local, gradient-based, error-triggered learning algorithm with online ternary weight updates. The proposed algorithm enables online training of multi-layer SNNs with memristive neuromorphic hardware showing a small loss in the performance compared with the state of the art. We also propose a hardware architecture based on memristive crossbar arrays to perform the required vector-matrix multiplications. The necessary peripheral circuitry including pre-synaptic, post-synaptic and write circuits required for online training, have been designed in the sub-threshold regime for power saving with a standard 180 nm CMOS process.