Five Pitfalls When Assessing Synthetic Medical Images with Reference Metrics

Reference metrics have been developed to objectively and quantitatively compare two images. Especially for evaluating the quality of reconstructed or compressed images, these metrics have shown very useful. Extensive tests of such metrics on benchmarks of artificially distorted natural images have revealed which metric best correlate with human perception of quality. Direct transfer of these metrics to the evaluation of generative models in medical imaging, however, can easily lead to pitfalls, because assumptions about image content, image data format and image interpretation are often very different. Also, the correlation of reference metrics and human perception of quality can vary strongly for different kinds of distortions and commonly used metrics, such as SSIM, PSNR and MAE are not the best choice for all situations. We selected five pitfalls that showcase unexpected and probably undesired reference metric scores and discuss strategies to avoid them.

Content-Based Image Retrieval for Multi-Class Volumetric Radiology Images: A Benchmark Study

While content-based image retrieval (CBIR) has been extensively studied in natural image retrieval, its application to medical images presents ongoing challenges, primarily due to the 3D nature of medical images. Recent studies have shown the potential use of pre-trained vision embeddings for CBIR in the context of radiology image retrieval. However, a benchmark for the retrieval of 3D volumetric medical images is still lacking, hindering the ability to objectively evaluate and compare the efficiency of proposed CBIR approaches in medical imaging. In this study, we extend previous work and establish a benchmark for region-based and multi-organ retrieval using the TotalSegmentator dataset (TS) with detailed multi-organ annotations. We benchmark embeddings derived from pre-trained supervised models on medical images against embeddings derived from pre-trained unsupervised models on non-medical images for 29 coarse and 104 detailed anatomical structures in volume and region levels. We adopt a late interaction re-ranking method inspired by text matching for image retrieval, comparing it against the original method proposed for volume and region retrieval achieving retrieval recall of 1.0 for diverse anatomical regions with a wide size range. The findings and methodologies presented in this paper provide essential insights and benchmarks for the development and evaluation of CBIR approaches in the context of medical imaging.

Similarity Metrics for MR Image-To-Image Translation

Image-to-image translation can create large impact in medical imaging, i.e. if images of a patient can be translated to another modality, type or sequence for better diagnosis. However, these methods must be validated by human reader studies, which are costly and restricted to small samples. Automatic evaluation of large samples to pre-evaluate and continuously improve methods before human validation is needed. In this study, we give an overview of reference and non-reference metrics for image synthesis assessment and investigate the ability of nine metrics, that need a reference (SSIM, MS-SSIM, PSNR, MSE, NMSE, MAE, LPIPS, NMI and PCC) and three non-reference metrics (BLUR, MSN, MNG) to detect 11 kinds of distortions in MR images from the BraSyn dataset. In addition we test a downstream segmentation metric and the effect of three normalization methods (Minmax, cMinMax and Zscore). Although PSNR and SSIM are frequently used to evaluate generative models for image-to-image-translation tasks in the medical domain, they show very specific shortcomings. SSIM ignores blurring but is very sensitive to intensity shifts in unnormalized MR images. PSNR is even more sensitive to different normalization methods and hardly measures the degree of distortions. Further metrics, such as LPIPS, NMI and DICE can be very useful to evaluate other similarity aspects. If the images to be compared are misaligned, most metrics are flawed. By carefully selecting and reasonably combining image similarity metrics, the training and selection of generative models for MR image synthesis can be improved. Many aspects of their output can be validated before final and costly evaluation by trained radiologists is conducted.

BraSyn 2023 challenge: Missing MRI synthesis and the effect of different learning objectives

This work addresses the Brain Magnetic Resonance Image Synthesis for Tumor Segmentation (BraSyn) challenge, which was hosted as part of the Brain Tumor Segmentation (BraTS) challenge in 2023. In this challenge, researchers are invited to synthesize a missing magnetic resonance image sequence, given other available sequences, to facilitate tumor segmentation pipelines trained on complete sets of image sequences. This problem can be tackled using deep learning within the framework of paired image-to-image translation. In this study, we propose investigating the effectiveness of a commonly used deep learning framework, such as Pix2Pix, trained under the supervision of different image-quality loss functions. Our results indicate that the use of different loss functions significantly affects the synthesis quality. We systematically study the impact of various loss functions in the multi-sequence MR image synthesis setting of the BraSyn challenge. Furthermore, we demonstrate how image synthesis performance can be optimized by combining different learning objectives beneficially.

Benchmarking Pretrained Vision Embeddings for Near- and Duplicate Detection in Medical Images

Near- and duplicate image detection is a critical concern in the field of medical imaging. Medical datasets often contain similar or duplicate images from various sources, which can lead to significant performance issues and evaluation biases, especially in machine learning tasks due to data leakage between training and testing subsets. In this paper, we present an approach for identifying near- and duplicate 3D medical images leveraging publicly available 2D computer vision embeddings. We assessed our approach by comparing embeddings extracted from two state-of-the-art self-supervised pretrained models and two different vector index structures for similarity retrieval. We generate an experimental benchmark based on the publicly available Medical Segmentation Decathlon dataset. The proposed method yields promising results for near- and duplicate image detection achieving a mean sensitivity and specificity of 0.9645 and 0.8559, respectively.

Medical Image Retrieval Using Pretrained Embeddings

A wide range of imaging techniques and data formats available for medical images make accurate retrieval from image databases challenging. Efficient retrieval systems are crucial in advancing medical research, enabling large-scale studies and innovative diagnostic tools. Thus, addressing the challenges of medical image retrieval is essential for the continued enhancement of healthcare and research. In this study, we evaluated the feasibility of employing four state-of-the-art pretrained models for medical image retrieval at modality, body region, and organ levels and compared the results of two similarity indexing approaches. Since the employed networks take 2D images, we analyzed the impacts of weighting and sampling strategies to incorporate 3D information during retrieval of 3D volumes. We showed that medical image retrieval is feasible using pretrained networks without any additional training or fine-tuning steps. Using pretrained embeddings, we achieved a recall of 1 for various tasks at modality, body region, and organ level.

Uncertainty Estimation in Contrast-Enhanced MR Image Translation with Multi-Axis Fusion

In recent years, deep learning has been applied to a wide range of medical imaging and image processing tasks. In this work, we focus on the estimation of epistemic uncertainty for 3D medical image-to-image translation. We propose a novel model uncertainty quantification method, Multi-Axis Fusion (MAF), which relies on the integration of complementary information derived from multiple views on volumetric image data. The proposed approach is applied to the task of synthesizing contrast enhanced T1-weighted images based on native T1, T2 and T2-FLAIR scans. The quantitative findings indicate a strong correlation ($\rho_{\text healthy} = 0.89$) between the mean absolute image synthetization error and the mean uncertainty score for our MAF method. Hence, we consider MAF as a promising approach to solve the highly relevant task of detecting synthetization failures at inference time.

fRegGAN with K-space Loss Regularization for Medical Image Translation

Generative adversarial networks (GANs) have shown remarkable success in generating realistic images and are increasingly used in medical imaging for image-to-image translation tasks. However, GANs tend to suffer from a frequency bias towards low frequencies, which can lead to the removal of important structures in the generated images. To address this issue, we propose a novel frequency-aware image-to-image translation framework based on the supervised RegGAN approach, which we call fRegGAN. The framework employs a K-space loss to regularize the frequency content of the generated images and incorporates well-known properties of MRI K-space geometry to guide the network training process. By combine our method with the RegGAN approach, we can mitigate the effect of training with misaligned data and frequency bias at the same time. We evaluate our method on the public BraTS dataset and outperform the baseline methods in terms of both quantitative and qualitative metrics when synthesizing T2-weighted from T1-weighted MR images. Detailed ablation studies are provided to understand the effect of each modification on the final performance. The proposed method is a step towards improving the performance of image-to-image translation and synthesis in the medical domain and shows promise for other applications in the field of image processing and generation.

Transfer Learning for Segmentation Problems: Choose the Right Encoder and Skip the Decoder

It is common practice to reuse models initially trained on different data to increase downstream task performance. Especially in the computer vision domain, ImageNet-pretrained weights have been successfully used for various tasks. In this work, we investigate the impact of transfer learning for segmentation problems, being pixel-wise classification problems that can be tackled with encoder-decoder architectures. We find that transfer learning the decoder does not help downstream segmentation tasks, while transfer learning the encoder is truly beneficial. We demonstrate that pretrained weights for a decoder may yield faster convergence, but they do not improve the overall model performance as one can obtain equivalent results with randomly initialized decoders. However, we show that it is more effective to reuse encoder weights trained on a segmentation or reconstruction task than reusing encoder weights trained on classification tasks. This finding implicates that using ImageNet-pretrained encoders for downstream segmentation problems is suboptimal. We also propose a contrastive self-supervised approach with multiple self-reconstruction tasks, which provides encoders that are suitable for transfer learning in segmentation problems in the absence of segmentation labels.

FAIR4Cov: Fused Audio Instance and Representation for COVID-19 Detection

Audio-based classification techniques on body sounds have long been studied to support diagnostic decisions, particularly in pulmonary diseases. In response to the urgency of the COVID-19 pandemic, a growing number of models are developed to identify COVID-19 patients based on acoustic input. Most models focus on cough because the dry cough is the best-known symptom of COVID-19. However, other body sounds, such as breath and speech, have also been revealed to correlate with COVID-19 as well. In this work, rather than relying on a specific body sound, we propose Fused Audio Instance and Representation for COVID-19 Detection (FAIR4Cov). It relies on constructing a joint feature vector obtained from a plurality of body sounds in waveform and spectrogram representation. The core component of FAIR4Cov is a self-attention fusion unit that is trained to establish the relation of multiple body sounds and audio representations and integrate it into a compact feature vector. We set up our experiments on different combinations of body sounds using only waveform, spectrogram, and a joint representation of waveform and spectrogram. Our findings show that the use of self-attention to combine extracted features from cough, breath, and speech sounds leads to the best performance with an Area Under the Receiver Operating Characteristic Curve (AUC) score of 0.8658, a sensitivity of 0.8057, and a specificity of 0.7958. This AUC is 0.0227 higher than the one of the models trained on spectrograms only and 0.0847 higher than the one of the models trained on waveforms only. The results demonstrate that the combination of spectrogram with waveform representation helps to enrich the extracted features and outperforms the models with single representation.