Combining Cognitive and Generative AI for Self-explanation in Interactive AI Agents

The Virtual Experimental Research Assistant (VERA) is an inquiry-based learning environment that empowers a learner to build conceptual models of complex ecological systems and experiment with agent-based simulations of the models. This study investigates the convergence of cognitive AI and generative AI for self-explanation in interactive AI agents such as VERA. From a cognitive AI viewpoint, we endow VERA with a functional model of its own design, knowledge, and reasoning represented in the Task--Method--Knowledge (TMK) language. From the perspective of generative AI, we use ChatGPT, LangChain, and Chain-of-Thought to answer user questions based on the VERA TMK model. Thus, we combine cognitive and generative AI to generate explanations about how VERA works and produces its answers. The preliminary evaluation of the generation of explanations in VERA on a bank of 66 questions derived from earlier work appears promising.

Machine Teaching for Building Modular AI Agents based on Zero-shot Learners

The recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have led to the creation of many modular AI agents. These agents employ LLMs as zero-shot learners to perform sub-tasks in order to solve complex tasks set forth by human users. We propose an approach to enhance the robustness and performance of modular AI agents that utilize LLMs as zero-shot learners. Our iterative machine teaching method offers an efficient way to teach AI agents over time with limited human feedback, addressing the limit posed by the quality of zero-shot learning. We advocate leveraging the data traces from initial deployments and outputs or annotations from the zero-shot learners to train smaller and task-specific substitute models which can reduce both the monetary costs and environmental impact. Our machine teaching process avails human expertise to correct examples with a high likelihood of misannotations. Results on three tasks, common to conversational AI agents, show that close-to-oracle performance can be achieved with supervision on 20-70% of the dataset depending upon the complexity of the task and performance of zero-shot learners.

Using Analytics on Student Created Data to Content Validate Pedagogical Tools

Conceptual and simulation models can function as useful pedagogical tools, however it is important to categorize different outcomes when evaluating them in order to more meaningfully interpret results. VERA is a ecology-based conceptual modeling software that enables users to simulate interactions between biotics and abiotics in an ecosystem, allowing users to form and then verify hypothesis through observing a time series of the species populations. In this paper, we classify this time series into common patterns found in the domain of ecological modeling through two methods, hierarchical clustering and curve fitting, illustrating a general methodology for showing content validity when combining different pedagogical tools. When applied to a diverse sample of 263 models containing 971 time series collected from three different VERA user categories: a Georgia Tech (GATECH), North Georgia Technical College (NGTC), and ``Self Directed Learners'', results showed agreement between both classification methods on 89.38\% of the sample curves in the test set. This serves as a good indication that our methodology for determining content validity was successful.

Human-AI Interaction Design in Machine Teaching

Machine Teaching (MT) is an interactive process where a human and a machine interact with the goal of training a machine learning model (ML) for a specified task. The human teacher communicates their task expertise and the machine student gathers the required data and knowledge to produce an ML model. MT systems are developed to jointly minimize the time spent on teaching and the learner's error rate. The design of human-AI interaction in an MT system not only impacts the teaching efficiency, but also indirectly influences the ML performance by affecting the teaching quality. In this paper, we build upon our previous work where we proposed an MT framework with three components, viz., the teaching interface, the machine learner, and the knowledge base, and focus on the human-AI interaction design involved in realizing the teaching interface. We outline design decisions that need to be addressed in developing an MT system beginning from an ML task. The paper follows the Socratic method entailing a dialogue between a curious student and a wise teacher.

Explanation as Question Answering based on a Task Model of the Agent's Design

We describe a stance towards the generation of explanations in AI agents that is both human-centered and design-based. We collect questions about the working of an AI agent through participatory design by focus groups. We capture an agent's design through a Task-Method-Knowledge model that explicitly specifies the agent's tasks and goals, as well as the mechanisms, knowledge and vocabulary it uses for accomplishing the tasks. We illustrate our approach through the generation of explanations in Skillsync, an AI agent that links companies and colleges for worker upskilling and reskilling. In particular, we embed a question-answering agent called AskJill in Skillsync, where AskJill contains a TMK model of Skillsync's design. AskJill presently answers human-generated questions about Skillsync's tasks and vocabulary, and thereby helps explain how it produces its recommendations.

Symmetry as a Representation of Intuitive Geometry?

Recognition of geometrical patterns seems to be an important aspect of human intelligence. Geometric pattern recognition is used in many intelligence tests, including Dehaene's odd-one-out test of Core Geometry (CG)) based on intuitive geometrical concepts (Dehaene et al., 2006). Earlier work has developed a symmetry-based cognitive model of Dehaene's test and demonstrated performance comparable to that of humans. In this work, we further investigate the role of symmetry in geometrical intuition and build a cognitive model for the 2-Alternative Forced Choice (2-AFC) variation of the CG test (Marupudi & Varma 2021). In contrast to Dehaene's test, 2-AFC leaves almost no space for cognitive models based on generalization over multiple examples. Our symmetry-based model achieves an accuracy comparable to the human average on the 2-AFC test and appears to capture an essential part of intuitive geometry.

A Framework for Interactive Knowledge-Aided Machine Teaching

Machine Teaching (MT) is an interactive process where humans train a machine learning model by playing the role of a teacher. The process of designing an MT system involves decisions that can impact both efficiency of human teachers and performance of machine learners. Previous research has proposed and evaluated specific MT systems but there is limited discussion on a general framework for designing them. We propose a framework for designing MT systems and also detail a system for the text classification problem as a specific instance. Our framework focuses on three components i.e. teaching interface, machine learner, and knowledge base; and their relations describe how each component can benefit the others. Our preliminary experiments show how MT systems can reduce both human teaching time and machine learner error rate.

Agent Smith: Teaching Question Answering to Jill Watson

Building AI agents can be costly. Consider a question answering agent such as Jill Watson that automatically answers students' questions on the discussion forums of online classes based on their syllabi and other course materials. Training a Jill on the syllabus of a new online class can take a hundred hours or more. Machine teaching - interactive teaching of an AI agent using synthetic data sets - can reduce the training time because it combines the advantages of knowledge-based AI, machine learning using large data sets, and interactive human-in-loop training. We describe Agent Smith, an interactive machine teaching agent that reduces the time taken to train a Jill for a new online class by an order of magnitude.

Explanation as Question Answering based on Design Knowledge

Explanation of an AI agent requires knowledge of its design and operation. An open question is how to identify, access and use this design knowledge for generating explanations. Many AI agents used in practice, such as intelligent tutoring systems fielded in educational contexts, typically come with a User Guide that explains what the agent does, how it works and how to use the agent. However, few humans actually read the User Guide in detail. Instead, most users seek answers to their questions on demand. In this paper, we describe a question answering agent (AskJill) that uses the User Guide for an interactive learning environment (VERA) to automatically answer questions and thereby explains the domain, functioning, and operation of VERA. We present a preliminary assessment of AskJill in VERA.

AI-Powered Learning: Making Education Accessible, Affordable, and Achievable

We have developed an AI-powered socio-technical system for making online learning in higher education more accessible, affordable and achievable. In particular, we have developed four novel and intertwined AI technologies: (1) VERA, a virtual experimentation research assistant for supporting inquiry-based learning of scientific knowledge, (2) Jill Watson Q&A, a virtual teaching assistant for answering questions based on educational documents including the VERA user reference guide, (3) Jill Watson SA, a virtual social agent that promotes online interactions, and (4) Agent Smith, that helps generate a Jill Watson Q&A agent for new documents such as class syllabi. The results are positive: (i) VERA enhances ecological knowledge and is freely available online; (ii) Jill Watson Q&A has been used by >4,000 students in >12 online classes and saved teachers >500 hours of work; (iii) Jill Q&A and Jill Watson SA promote learner engagement, interaction, and community; and (iv). Agent Smith helps generate Jill Watson Q&A for a new syllabus within ~25 hours. Put together, these innovative technologies help make online learning simultaneously more accessible (by making materials available online), affordable (by saving teacher time), and achievable (by providing learning assistance and fostering student engagement).