Enhancing Crime Scene Investigations through Virtual Reality and Deep Learning Techniques

The analysis of a crime scene is a pivotal activity in forensic investigations. Crime Scene Investigators and forensic science practitioners rely on best practices, standard operating procedures, and critical thinking, to produce rigorous scientific reports to document the scenes of interest and meet the quality standards expected in the courts. However, crime scene examination is a complex and multifaceted task often performed in environments susceptible to deterioration, contamination, and alteration, despite the use of contact-free and non-destructive methods of analysis. In this context, the documentation of the sites, and the identification and isolation of traces of evidential value remain challenging endeavours. In this paper, we propose a photogrammetric reconstruction of the crime scene for inspection in virtual reality (VR) and focus on fully automatic object recognition with deep learning (DL) algorithms through a client-server architecture. A pre-trained Faster-RCNN model was chosen as the best method that can best categorize relevant objects at the scene, selected by experts in the VR environment. These operations can considerably improve and accelerate crime scene analysis and help the forensic expert in extracting measurements and analysing in detail the objects under analysis. Experimental results on a simulated crime scene have shown that the proposed method can be effective in finding and recognizing objects with potential evidentiary value, enabling timely analyses of crime scenes, particularly those with health and safety risks (e.g. fires, explosions, chemicals, etc.), while minimizing subjective bias and contamination of the scene.

Deepfake Media Forensics: State of the Art and Challenges Ahead

AI-generated synthetic media, also called Deepfakes, have significantly influenced so many domains, from entertainment to cybersecurity. Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) and Diffusion Models (DMs) are the main frameworks used to create Deepfakes, producing highly realistic yet fabricated content. While these technologies open up new creative possibilities, they also bring substantial ethical and security risks due to their potential misuse. The rise of such advanced media has led to the development of a cognitive bias known as Impostor Bias, where individuals doubt the authenticity of multimedia due to the awareness of AI's capabilities. As a result, Deepfake detection has become a vital area of research, focusing on identifying subtle inconsistencies and artifacts with machine learning techniques, especially Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs). Research in forensic Deepfake technology encompasses five main areas: detection, attribution and recognition, passive authentication, detection in realistic scenarios, and active authentication. Each area tackles specific challenges, from tracing the origins of synthetic media and examining its inherent characteristics for authenticity. This paper reviews the primary algorithms that address these challenges, examining their advantages, limitations, and future prospects.

DeepFeatureX Net: Deep Features eXtractors based Network for discriminating synthetic from real images

Deepfakes, synthetic images generated by deep learning algorithms, represent one of the biggest challenges in the field of Digital Forensics. The scientific community is working to develop approaches that can discriminate the origin of digital images (real or AI-generated). However, these methodologies face the challenge of generalization, that is, the ability to discern the nature of an image even if it is generated by an architecture not seen during training. This usually leads to a drop in performance. In this context, we propose a novel approach based on three blocks called Base Models, each of which is responsible for extracting the discriminative features of a specific image class (Diffusion Model-generated, GAN-generated, or real) as it is trained by exploiting deliberately unbalanced datasets. The features extracted from each block are then concatenated and processed to discriminate the origin of the input image. Experimental results showed that this approach not only demonstrates good robust capabilities to JPEG compression but also outperforms state-of-the-art methods in several generalization tests. Code, models and dataset are available at https://github.com/opontorno/block-based_deepfake-detection.

On the Exploitation of DCT-Traces in the Generative-AI Domain

Deepfakes represent one of the toughest challenges in the world of Cybersecurity and Digital Forensics, especially considering the high-quality results obtained with recent generative AI-based solutions. Almost all generative models leave unique traces in synthetic data that, if analyzed and identified in detail, can be exploited to improve the generalization limitations of existing deepfake detectors. In this paper we analyzed deepfake images in the frequency domain generated by both GAN and Diffusion Model engines, examining in detail the underlying statistical distribution of Discrete Cosine Transform (DCT) coefficients. Recognizing that not all coefficients contribute equally to image detection, we hypothesize the existence of a unique "discriminative fingerprint", embedded in specific combinations of coefficients. To identify them, Machine Learning classifiers were trained on various combinations of coefficients. In addition, the Explainable AI (XAI) LIME algorithm was used to search for intrinsic discriminative combinations of coefficients. Finally, we performed a robustness test to analyze the persistence of traces by applying JPEG compression. The experimental results reveal the existence of traces left by the generative models that are more discriminative and persistent at JPEG attacks.

MITS-GAN: Safeguarding Medical Imaging from Tampering with Generative Adversarial Networks

The progress in generative models, particularly Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs), opened new possibilities for image generation but raised concerns about potential malicious uses, especially in sensitive areas like medical imaging. This study introduces MITS-GAN, a novel approach to prevent tampering in medical images, with a specific focus on CT scans. The approach disrupts the output of the attacker's CT-GAN architecture by introducing imperceptible but yet precise perturbations. Specifically, the proposed approach involves the introduction of appropriate Gaussian noise to the input as a protective measure against various attacks. Our method aims to enhance tamper resistance, comparing favorably to existing techniques. Experimental results on a CT scan dataset demonstrate MITS-GAN's superior performance, emphasizing its ability to generate tamper-resistant images with negligible artifacts. As image tampering in medical domains poses life-threatening risks, our proactive approach contributes to the responsible and ethical use of generative models. This work provides a foundation for future research in countering cyber threats in medical imaging. Models and codes are publicly available at the following link \url{https://iplab.dmi.unict.it/MITS-GAN-2024/}.

A Novel Dataset for Non-Destructive Inspection of Handwritten Documents

Forensic handwriting examination is a branch of Forensic Science that aims to examine handwritten documents in order to properly define or hypothesize the manuscript's author. These analysis involves comparing two or more (digitized) documents through a comprehensive comparison of intrinsic local and global features. If a correlation exists and specific best practices are satisfied, then it will be possible to affirm that the documents under analysis were written by the same individual. The need to create sophisticated tools capable of extracting and comparing significant features has led to the development of cutting-edge software with almost entirely automated processes, improving the forensic examination of handwriting and achieving increasingly objective evaluations. This is made possible by algorithmic solutions based on purely mathematical concepts. Machine Learning and Deep Learning models trained with specific datasets could turn out to be the key elements to best solve the task at hand. In this paper, we proposed a new and challenging dataset consisting of two subsets: the first consists of 21 documents written either by the classic ``pen and paper" approach (and later digitized) and directly acquired on common devices such as tablets; the second consists of 362 handwritten manuscripts by 124 different people, acquired following a specific pipeline. Our study pioneered a comparison between traditionally handwritten documents and those produced with digital tools (e.g., tablets). Preliminary results on the proposed datasets show that 90% classification accuracy can be achieved on the first subset (documents written on both paper and pen and later digitized and on tablets) and 96% on the second portion of the data. The datasets are available at https://iplab.dmi.unict.it/mfs/forensic-handwriting-analysis/novel-dataset-2023/.

AI Mirage: The Impostor Bias and the Deepfake Detection Challenge in the Era of Artificial Illusions

This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of cognitive biases in forensics and digital forensics, examining their implications for decision-making processes in these fields. It explores the various types of cognitive biases that may arise during forensic investigations and digital forensic analyses, such as confirmation bias, expectation bias, overconfidence in errors, contextual bias, and attributional biases. It also evaluates existing methods and techniques used to mitigate cognitive biases in these contexts, assessing the effectiveness of interventions aimed at reducing biases and improving decision-making outcomes. Additionally, this paper introduces a new cognitive bias, called "impostor bias", that may affect the use of generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) tools in forensics and digital forensics. The impostor bias is the tendency to doubt the authenticity or validity of the output generated by AI tools, such as deepfakes, in the form of audio, images, and videos. This bias may lead to erroneous judgments or false accusations, undermining the reliability and credibility of forensic evidence. The paper discusses the potential causes and consequences of the impostor bias, and suggests some strategies to prevent or counteract it. By addressing these topics, this paper seeks to offer valuable insights into understanding cognitive biases in forensic practices and provide recommendations for future research and practical applications to enhance the objectivity and validity of forensic investigations.

Improving Video Deepfake Detection: A DCT-Based Approach with Patch-Level Analysis

The term deepfake refers to all those multimedia contents that were synthetically altered or created from scratch through the use of generative models. This phenomenon has become widespread due to the use of increasingly accurate and efficient architectures capable of rendering manipulated content indistinguishable from real content. In order to fight the illicit use of this powerful technology, it has become necessary to develop algorithms able to distinguish synthetic content from real ones. In this study, a new algorithm for the detection of deepfakes in digital videos is presented, focusing on the main goal of creating a fast and explainable method from a forensic perspective. To achieve this goal, the I-frames were extracted in order to provide faster computation and analysis than approaches described in literature. In addition, to identify the most discriminating regions within individual video frames, the entire frame, background, face, eyes, nose, mouth, and face frame were analyzed separately. From the Discrete Cosine Transform (DCT), the Beta components were extracted from the AC coefficients and used as input to standard classifiers (e.g., k-NN, SVM, and others) in order to identify those frequencies most discriminative for solving the task in question. Experimental results obtained on the Faceforensics++ and Celeb-DF (v2) datasets show that the eye and mouth regions are those most discriminative and able to determine the nature of the video with greater reliability than the analysis of the whole frame. The method proposed in this study is analytical, fast and does not require much computational power.

Innovative Methods for Non-Destructive Inspection of Handwritten Documents

Handwritten document analysis is an area of forensic science, with the goal of establishing authorship of documents through examination of inherent characteristics. Law enforcement agencies use standard protocols based on manual processing of handwritten documents. This method is time-consuming, is often subjective in its evaluation, and is not replicable. To overcome these limitations, in this paper we present a framework capable of extracting and analyzing intrinsic measures of manuscript documents related to text line heights, space between words, and character sizes using image processing and deep learning techniques. The final feature vector for each document involved consists of the mean and standard deviation for every type of measure collected. By quantifying the Euclidean distance between the feature vectors of the documents to be compared, authorship can be discerned. We also proposed a new and challenging dataset consisting of 362 handwritten manuscripts written on paper and digital devices by 124 different people. Our study pioneered the comparison between traditionally handwritten documents and those produced with digital tools (e.g., tablets). Experimental results demonstrate the ability of our method to objectively determine authorship in different writing media, outperforming the state of the art.

Not with my name! Inferring artists' names of input strings employed by Diffusion Models

Diffusion Models (DM) are highly effective at generating realistic, high-quality images. However, these models lack creativity and merely compose outputs based on their training data, guided by a textual input provided at creation time. Is it acceptable to generate images reminiscent of an artist, employing his name as input? This imply that if the DM is able to replicate an artist's work then it was trained on some or all of his artworks thus violating copyright. In this paper, a preliminary study to infer the probability of use of an artist's name in the input string of a generated image is presented. To this aim we focused only on images generated by the famous DALL-E 2 and collected images (both original and generated) of five renowned artists. Finally, a dedicated Siamese Neural Network was employed to have a first kind of probability. Experimental results demonstrate that our approach is an optimal starting point and can be employed as a prior for predicting a complete input string of an investigated image. Dataset and code are available at: https://github.com/ictlab-unict/not-with-my-name .