Selection of Filters for Photonic Crystal Spectrometer Using Domain-Aware Evolutionary Algorithms

This work addresses the critical challenge of optimal filter selection for a novel trace gas measurement device. This device uses photonic crystal filters to retrieve trace gas concentrations prone to photon and read noise. The filter selection directly influences accuracy and precision of the gas retrieval and therefore is a crucial performance driver. We formulate the problem as a stochastic combinatorial optimization problem and develop a simulator mimicking gas retrieval with noise. The objective function for selecting filters reducing retrieval error is minimized by the employed metaheuristics, that represent various families of optimizers. We aim to improve the found top-performing algorithms using our novel distance-driven extensions, that employ metrics on the space of filter selections. This leads to a novel adaptation of the UMDA algorithm, we call UMDA-U-PLS-Dist, equipped with one of the proposed distance metrics as the most efficient and robust solver among the considered ones. Analysis of filter sets produced by this method reveals that filters with relatively smooth transmission profiles but containing high contrast improve the device performance. Moreover, the top-performing obtained solution shows significant improvement compared to the baseline.

Sampling in CMA-ES: Low Numbers of Low Discrepancy Points

The Covariance Matrix Adaptation Evolution Strategy (CMA-ES) is one of the most successful examples of a derandomized evolution strategy. However, it still relies on randomly sampling offspring, which can be done via a uniform distribution and subsequently transforming into the required Gaussian. Previous work has shown that replacing this uniform sampling with a low-discrepancy sampler, such as Halton or Sobol sequences, can improve performance over a wide set of problems. We show that iterating through small, fixed sets of low-discrepancy points can still perform better than the default uniform distribution. Moreover, using only 128 points throughout the search is sufficient to closely approximate the empirical performance of using the complete pseudorandom sequence up to dimensionality 40 on the BBOB benchmark. For lower dimensionalities (below 10), we find that using as little as 32 unique low discrepancy points performs similar or better than uniform sampling. In 2D, for which we have highly optimized low discrepancy samples available, we demonstrate that using these points yields the highest empirical performance and requires only 16 samples to improve over uniform sampling. Overall, we establish a clear relation between the $L_2$ discrepancy of the used point set and the empirical performance of the CMA-ES.

Impact of spatial transformations on landscape features of CEC2022 basic benchmark problems

When benchmarking optimization heuristics, we need to take care to avoid an algorithm exploiting biases in the construction of the used problems. One way in which this might be done is by providing different versions of each problem but with transformations applied to ensure the algorithms are equipped with mechanisms for successfully tackling a range of problems. In this paper, we investigate several of these problem transformations and show how they influence the low-level landscape features of a set of 5 problems from the CEC2022 benchmark suite. Our results highlight that even relatively small transformations can significantly alter the measured landscape features. This poses a wider question of what properties we want to preserve when creating problem transformations, and how to fairly measure them.