Enhancing super-resolution ultrasound localisation through multi-frame deconvolution exploiting spatiotemporal coherence

Super-resolution ultrasound imaging through microbubble (MB) localisation and tracking, also known as ultrasound localisation microscopy, allows non-invasive sub-diffraction resolution imaging of microvasculature in animals and humans. The number of MBs localised from the acquired contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) images and the localisation precision directly influence the quality of the resulting super-resolution microvasculature images. However, non-negligible noise present in the CEUS images can make localising MBs challenging. To enhance the MB localisation performance, we propose a Multi-Frame Deconvolution (MF-Decon) framework that can exploit the spatiotemporal coherence inherent in the CEUS data, with new spatial and temporal regularisers designed based on total variation (TV) and regularisation by denoising (RED). Based on the MF-Decon framework, we introduce two novel methods: MF-Decon with spatial and temporal TVs (MF-Decon+3DTV) and MF-Decon with spatial RED and temporal TV (MF-Decon+RED+TV). Results from in silico simulations indicate that our methods outperform two widely used methods using deconvolution or normalised cross-correlation across all evaluation metrics, including precision, recall, $F_1$ score, mean and standard localisation errors. In particular, our methods improve MB localisation precision by up to 39% and recall by up to 12%. Super-resolution microvasculature maps generated with our methods on a publicly available in vivo rat brain dataset show less noise, better contrast, higher resolution and more vessel structures.

Ultrafast 3-D Super Resolution Ultrasound using Row-Column Array specific Coherence-based Beamforming and Rolling Acoustic Sub-aperture Processing: In Vitro, In Vivo and Clinical Study

The row-column addressed array is an emerging probe for ultrafast 3-D ultrasound imaging. It achieves this with far fewer independent electronic channels and a wider field of view than traditional 2-D matrix arrays, of the same channel count, making it a good candidate for clinical translation. However, the image quality of row-column arrays is generally poor, particularly when investigating tissue. Ultrasound localisation microscopy allows for the production of super-resolution images even when the initial image resolution is not high. Unfortunately, the row-column probe can suffer from imaging artefacts that can degrade the quality of super-resolution images as `secondary' lobes from bright microbubbles can be mistaken as microbubble events, particularly when operated using plane wave imaging. These false events move through the image in a physiologically realistic way so can be challenging to remove via tracking, leading to the production of 'false vessels'. Here, a new type of rolling window image reconstruction procedure was developed, which integrated a row-column array-specific coherence-based beamforming technique with acoustic sub-aperture processing for the purposes of reducing `secondary' lobe artefacts, noise and increasing the effective frame rate. Using an {\it{in vitro}} cross tube, it was found that the procedure reduced the percentage of `false' locations from $\sim$26\% to $\sim$15\% compared to traditional orthogonal plane wave compounding. Additionally, it was found that the noise could be reduced by $\sim$7 dB and that the effective frame rate could be increased to over 4000 fps. Subsequently, {\it{in vivo}} ultrasound localisation microscopy was used to produce images non-invasively of a rabbit kidney and a human thyroid.

On the Use of Singular Value Decomposition as a Clutter Filter for Ultrasound Flow Imaging

Filtering based on Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) provides substantial separation of clutter, flow and noise in high frame rate ultrasound flow imaging. The use of SVD as a clutter filter has greatly improved techniques such as vector flow imaging, functional ultrasound and super-resolution ultrasound localization microscopy. The removal of clutter and noise relies on the assumption that tissue, flow and noise are each represented by different subsets of singular values, so that their signals are uncorrelated and lay on orthogonal sub-spaces. This assumption fails in the presence of tissue motion, for near-wall or microvascular flow, and can be influenced by an incorrect choice of singular value thresholds. Consequently, separation of flow, clutter and noise is imperfect, which can lead to image artefacts not present in the original data. Temporal and spatial fluctuation in intensity are the commonest artefacts, which vary in appearance and strengths. Ghosting and splitting artefacts are observed in the microvasculature where the flow signal is sparsely distributed. Singular value threshold selection, tissue motion, frame rate, flow signal amplitude and acquisition length affect the prevalence of these artefacts. Understanding what causes artefacts due to SVD clutter and noise removal is necessary for their interpretation.

BUbble Flow Field: a Simulation Framework for Evaluating Ultrasound Localization Microscopy Algorithms

Ultrasound contrast enhanced imaging has seen widespread uptake in research and clinical diagnostic imaging. This includes applications such as vector flow imaging, functional ultrasound and super-resolution Ultrasound Localization Microscopy (ULM). All of these require testing and validation during development of new algorithms with ground truth data. In this work we present a comprehensive simulation platform BUbble Flow Field (BUFF) that generates contrast enhanced ultrasound images in vascular tree geometries with realistic flow characteristics and validation algorithms for ULM. BUFF allows complex micro-vascular network generation of random and user-defined vascular networks. Blood flow is simulated with a fast Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) solver and allows arbitrary input and output positions and custom pressures. The acoustic field simulation is combined with non-linear Microbubble (MB) dynamics and simulates a range of point spread functions based on user-defined MB characteristics. The validation combines both binary and quantitative metrics. BFF's capacity to generate and validate user-defined networks is demonstrated through its implementation in the Ultrasound Localisation and TRacking Algorithms for Super Resolution (ULTRA-SR) Challenge at the International Ultrasonics Symposium (IUS) 2022 of the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE). The ability to produce ULM images, and the availability of a ground truth in localisation and tracking enables objective and quantitative evaluation of the large number of localisation and tracking algorithms developed in the field. BUFF can also benefit deep learning based methods by automatically generating datasets for training. BUFF is a fully comprehensive simulation platform for testing and validation of novel ULM techniques and is open source.

3D Super-Resolution Ultrasound with Adaptive Weight-Based Beamforming

Super-resolution ultrasound (SRUS) imaging through localising and tracking sparse microbubbles has been shown to reveal microvascular structure and flow beyond the wave diffraction limit. Most SRUS studies use standard delay and sum (DAS) beamforming, where large main lobe and significant side lobes make separation and localisation of densely distributed bubbles challenging, particularly in 3D due to the typically small aperture of matrix array probes. This study aims to improve 3D SRUS by implementing a low-cost 3D coherence beamformer based on channel signal variance, as well as two other adaptive weight-based coherence beamformers: nonlinear beamforming with p-th root compression and coherence factor. The 3D coherence beamformers, together with DAS, are compared in computer simulation, on a microflow phantom, and in vivo. Simulation results demonstrate that the adaptive weight-based beamformers can significantly narrow the main lobe and suppress the side lobes for modest computational cost. Significantly improved 3D SR images of microflow phantom and a rabbit kidney are obtained through the adaptive weight-based beamformers. The proposed variance-based beamformer performs best in simulations and experiments.

Fast and selective super-resolution ultrasound in vivo with sono-switchable nanodroplets

Perfusion by the microcirculation is key to the development, maintenance and pathology of tissue. Its measurement with high spatiotemporal resolution is consequently valuable but remains a challenge in deep tissue. Ultrasound Localization Microscopy (ULM) provides very high spatiotemporal resolution but the use of microbubbles requires low contrast agent concentrations, a long acquisition time, and gives little control over the spatial and temporal distribution of the bubbles. The present study is the first to demonstrate Acoustic Wave Sparsely-Activated Localization Microscopy (AWSALM) and fast-AWSALM for in vivo super-resolution ultrasound imaging, offering contrast on demand and vascular selectivity. Three different formulations of sono-switchable contrast agents were tested. We demonstrate their use with ultrasound mechanical indices well within recommended safety limits to enable fast on-demand sparse switching at very high agent concentrations. We produce super-localization maps of the rabbit renal vasculature with acquisition times between 5.5 s and 0.25 s, and an 4-fold improvement in spatial resolution. We present the unique selectivity of AWSALM in visualizing specific vascular branches and downstream microvasculature, and we show super-localized kidney structures in systole and diastole with fast-AWSALM. In conclusion we demonstrate the feasibility of fast and selective measurement of microvascular dynamics in vivo with subwavelength resolution using ultrasound and sono-switchable nanodroplets.

High contrast Ultrafast 3D Ultrasound Imaging using Row Column specific Frame Multiply and Sum

Row-column arrays have shown to be able to generate 3-D ultrafast ultrasound images with an order of magnitude less independent electronic channels than classic 2D matrix arrays. Unfortunately row-column array images suffer from major imaging artefacts due to the high side lobes. This paper proposes a row-column specific beamforming technique that exploits the incoherent nature of certain row column array artefacts. The geometric mean of the data from each row and column pair is taken prior to summation in beamforming, thus drastically reducing incoherent imaging artefacts compared to traditional coherent compounding. The effectiveness of this technique was demonstrated in silico, and the results show an average fivefold reduction in side-lobe levels. Significantly improved contrast was demonstrated with Tissue-to-noise ratio increasing from $\sim$10dB to $\sim$30dB and Tissue Contrast Ratio increasing from $\sim$21dB to $\sim$42dB when using the proposed new method compared to Delay and Sum. These new techniques allowed for high quality 3D imaging whilst maintaining high frame rate potential.