Instruct or Interact? Exploring and Eliciting LLMs' Capability in Code Snippet Adaptation Through Prompt Engineering

Code snippet adaptation is a fundamental activity in the software development process. Unlike code generation, code snippet adaptation is not a "free creation", which requires developers to tailor a given code snippet in order to fit specific requirements and the code context. Recently, large language models (LLMs) have confirmed their effectiveness in the code generation task with promising results. However, their performance on adaptation, a reuse-oriented and context-dependent code change prediction task, is still unclear. To bridge this gap, we conduct an empirical study to investigate the performance and issues of LLMs on the adaptation task. We first evaluate the adaptation performances of three popular LLMs and compare them to the code generation task. Our result indicates that their adaptation ability is weaker than generation, with a nearly 15% decrease on pass@1 and more context-related errors. By manually inspecting 200 cases, we further investigate the causes of LLMs' sub-optimal performance, which can be classified into three categories, i.e., Unclear Requirement, Requirement Misalignment and Context Misapplication. Based on the above empirical research, we propose an interactive prompting approach to eliciting LLMs' adaptation ability. Experimental result reveals that our approach greatly improve LLMs' adaptation performance. The best-performing Human-LLM interaction successfully solves 159 out of the 202 identified defects and improves the pass@1 and pass@5 by over 40% compared to the initial instruction-based prompt. Considering human efforts, we suggest multi-agent interaction as a trade-off, which can achieve comparable performance with excellent generalization ability. We deem that our approach could provide methodological assistance for autonomous code snippet reuse and adaptation with LLMs.

ROS package search for robot software development: a knowledge graph-based approach

ROS (Robot Operating System) packages have become increasingly popular as a type of software artifact that can be effectively reused in robotic software development. Indeed, finding suitable ROS packages that closely match the software's functional requirements from the vast number of available packages is a nontrivial task using current search methods. The traditional search methods for ROS packages often involve inputting keywords related to robotic tasks into general-purpose search engines or code hosting platforms to obtain approximate results of all potentially suitable ROS packages. However, the accuracy of these search methods remains relatively low because the task-related keywords may not precisely match the functionalities offered by the ROS packages. To improve the search accuracy of ROS packages, this paper presents a novel semantic-based search approach that relies on the semantic-level ROS Package Knowledge Graph (RPKG) to automatically retrieve the most suitable ROS packages. Firstly, to construct the RPKG, we employ multi-dimensional feature extraction techniques to extract semantic concepts from the dataset of ROS package text descriptions. The semantic features extracted from this process result in a substantial number of entities and relationships. Subsequently, we create a robot domain-specific small corpus and further fine-tune a pre-trained language model, BERT-ROS, to generate embeddings that effectively represent the semantics of the extracted features. These embeddings play a crucial role in facilitating semantic-level understanding and comparisons during the ROS package search process within the RPKG. Secondly, we introduce a novel semantic matching-based search algorithm that incorporates the weighted similarities of multiple features from user search queries, which searches out more accurate ROS packages than the traditional keyword search method.