Parallel Log Spectra index : a quality metric in large scale resting EEG preprocessing

Toward large scale electrophysiology data analysis, many preprocessing pipelines are developed to reject artifacts as the prerequisite step before the downstream analysis. A mainstay of these pipelines is based on the data driven approach -- Independent Component Analysis (ICA). Nevertheless, there is little effort put to the preprocessing quality control. In this paper, attentions to this issue were carefully paid by our observation that after running ICA based preprocessing pipeline: some subjects showed approximately Parallel multichannel Log power Spectra (PaLOS), namely, multichannel power spectra are proportional to each other. Firstly, the presence of PaLOS and its implications to connectivity analysis were described by real instance and simulation; secondly, we built its mathematical model and proposed the PaLOS index (PaLOSi) based on the common principal component analysis to detect its presence; thirdly, the performance of PaLOSi was tested on 30094 cases of EEG from 5 databases. The results showed that 1) the PaLOS implies a sole source which is physiologically implausible. 2) PaLOSi can detect the excessive elimination of brain components and is robust in terms of channel number, electrode layout, reference, and the other factors. 3) PaLOSi can output the channel and frequency wise index to help for in-depth check. This paper presented the PaLOS issue in the quality control step after running the preprocessing pipeline and the proposed PaLOSi may serve as a novel data quality metric in the large-scale automatic preprocessing.