Process for Adapting Language Models to Society (PALMS) with Values-Targeted Datasets

Language models can generate harmful and biased outputs and exhibit undesirable behavior. We propose a Process for Adapting Language Models to Society (PALMS) with Values-Targeted Datasets, an iterative process to significantly change model behavior by crafting and fine-tuning on a dataset that reflects a predetermined set of target values. We evaluate our process using three metrics: quantitative metrics with human evaluations that score output adherence to a target value, and toxicity scoring on outputs; and qualitative metrics analyzing the most common word associated with a given social category. Through each iteration, we add additional training dataset examples based on observed shortcomings from evaluations. PALMS performs significantly better on all metrics compared to baseline and control models for a broad range of GPT-3 language model sizes without compromising capability integrity. We find that the effectiveness of PALMS increases with model size. We show that significantly adjusting language model behavior is feasible with a small, hand-curated dataset.

Neural Network Surgery with Sets

The cost to train machine learning models has been increasing exponentially, making exploration and research into the correct features and architecture a costly or intractable endeavor at scale. However, using a technique named "surgery" OpenAI Five was continuously trained to play the game DotA 2 over the course of 10 months through 20 major changes in features and architecture. Surgery transfers trained weights from one network to another after a selection process to determine which sections of the model are unchanged and which must be re-initialized. In the past, the selection process relied on heuristics, manual labor, or pre-existing boundaries in the structure of the model, limiting the ability to salvage experiments after modifications of the feature set or input reorderings. We propose a solution to automatically determine which components of a neural network model should be salvaged and which require retraining. We achieve this by allowing the model to operate over discrete sets of features and use set-based operations to determine the exact relationship between inputs and outputs, and how they change across tweaks in model architecture. In this paper, we introduce the methodology for enabling neural networks to operate on sets, derive two methods for detecting feature-parameter interaction maps, and show their equivalence. We empirically validate that we can surgery weights across feature and architecture changes to the OpenAI Five model.

Dota 2 with Large Scale Deep Reinforcement Learning

On April 13th, 2019, OpenAI Five became the first AI system to defeat the world champions at an esports game. The game of Dota 2 presents novel challenges for AI systems such as long time horizons, imperfect information, and complex, continuous state-action spaces, all challenges which will become increasingly central to more capable AI systems. OpenAI Five leveraged existing reinforcement learning techniques, scaled to learn from batches of approximately 2 million frames every 2 seconds. We developed a distributed training system and tools for continual training which allowed us to train OpenAI Five for 10 months. By defeating the Dota 2 world champion (Team OG), OpenAI Five demonstrates that self-play reinforcement learning can achieve superhuman performance on a difficult task.