Insights from Network Science can advance Deep Graph Learning

Deep graph learning and network science both analyze graphs but approach similar problems from different perspectives. Whereas network science focuses on models and measures that reveal the organizational principles of complex systems with explicit assumptions, deep graph learning focuses on flexible and generalizable models that learn patterns in graph data in an automated fashion. Despite these differences, both fields share the same goal: to better model and understand patterns in graph-structured data. Early efforts to integrate methods, models, and measures from network science and deep graph learning indicate significant untapped potential. In this position, we explore opportunities at their intersection. We discuss open challenges in deep graph learning, including data augmentation, improved evaluation practices, higher-order models, and pooling methods. Likewise, we highlight challenges in network science, including scaling to massive graphs, integrating continuous gradient-based optimization, and developing standardized benchmarks.

Hierarchical Graph Pooling Based on Minimum Description Length

Graph pooling is an essential part of deep graph representation learning. We introduce MapEqPool, a principled pooling operator that takes the inherent hierarchical structure of real-world graphs into account. MapEqPool builds on the map equation, an information-theoretic objective function for community detection based on the minimum description length principle which naturally implements Occam's razor and balances between model complexity and fit. We demonstrate MapEqPool's competitive performance with an empirical comparison against various baselines across standard graph classification datasets.

From Link Prediction to Forecasting: Information Loss in Batch-based Temporal Graph Learning

Dynamic link prediction is an important problem considered by many recent works proposing various approaches for learning temporal edge patterns. To assess their efficacy, models are evaluated on publicly available benchmark datasets involving continuous-time and discrete-time temporal graphs. However, as we show in this work, the suitability of common batch-oriented evaluation depends on the datasets' characteristics, which can cause two issues: First, for continuous-time temporal graphs, fixed-size batches create time windows with different durations, resulting in an inconsistent dynamic link prediction task. Second, for discrete-time temporal graphs, the sequence of batches can additionally introduce temporal dependencies that are not present in the data. In this work, we empirically show that this common evaluation approach leads to skewed model performance and hinders the fair comparison of methods. We mitigate this problem by reformulating dynamic link prediction as a link forecasting task that better accounts for temporal information present in the data. We provide implementations of our new evaluation method for commonly used graph learning frameworks.

The Map Equation Goes Neural

Community detection and graph clustering are essential for unsupervised data exploration and understanding the high-level organisation of networked systems. Recently, graph clustering has been highlighted as an under-explored primary task for graph neural networks. While hierarchical graph pooling has been shown to improve performance in graph and node classification tasks, it performs poorly in identifying meaningful clusters. Community detection has a long history in network science, but typically relies on optimising objective functions with custom-tailored search algorithms, not leveraging recent advances in deep learning, particularly from graph neural networks. In this paper, we narrow this gap between the deep learning and network science communities. We consider the map equation, an information-theoretic objective function for community detection. Expressing it in a fully differentiable tensor form that produces soft cluster assignments, we optimise the map equation with deep learning through gradient descent. More specifically, the reformulated map equation is a loss function compatible with any graph neural network architecture, enabling flexible clustering and graph pooling that clusters both graph structure and data features in an end-to-end way, automatically finding an optimum number of clusters without explicit regularisation. We evaluate our approach experimentally using different neural network architectures for unsupervised clustering in synthetic and real data. Our results show that our approach achieves competitive performance against baselines, naturally detects overlapping communities, and avoids over-partitioning sparse graphs.