In realistic applications of object search, robots will need to locate target objects in complex environments while coping with unreliable sensors, especially for small or hard-to-detect objects. In such settings, correlational information can be valuable for planning efficiently: when looking for a fork, the robot could start by locating the easier-to-detect refrigerator, since forks would probably be found nearby. Previous approaches to object search with correlational information typically resort to ad-hoc or greedy search strategies. In this paper, we propose the Correlational Object Search POMDP (COS-POMDP), which can be solved to produce search strategies that use correlational information. COS-POMDPs contain a correlation-based observation model that allows us to avoid the exponential blow-up of maintaining a joint belief about all objects, while preserving the optimal solution to this naive, exponential POMDP formulation. We propose a hierarchical planning algorithm to scale up COS-POMDP for practical domains. We conduct experiments using AI2-THOR, a realistic simulator of household environments, as well as YOLOv5, a widely-used object detector. Our results show that, particularly for hard-to-detect objects, such as scrub brush and remote control, our method offers the most robust performance compared to baselines that ignore correlations as well as a greedy, next-best view approach.