Token-free LLMs Can Generate Chinese Classical Poetry with More Accurate Format

Finetuned large language models (such as ChatGPT and Qwen-chat) can generate Chinese classical poetry following human's instructions. LLMs perform well in content, but are usually lacking in format, with occasionally excess or insufficient number of characters in each line. Since most SOTA LLMs are token-based, we assume that the format inaccuracy is due to the difficulty of the "token planning" task, which means that the LLM need to know exactly how much characters are contained in each token and do length-control planning based on that knowledge. In this paper, we first confirm our assumption by showing that existing token-based large language models has limited knowledge on token-character relationship. We use a spelling bee probing procedure, and find that Qwen-chat failed in nearly 15% Chinese spelling test. We then show that a token-based model can be easily tailored into a token-free model (in terms of Chinese), which can largely solve the format accuracy problem. Our tailoring procedure removes long-tokens from the vocabulary and the language model head, and keeps only character-level or byte-level tokens. As part of our contribution, we release the finetuned token-free model (which is based on Qwen-chat-7B), which can generate chinese classical poetry following complex instructions like LLMs (such as story paraphrasing), and also perform well in format. On the test set, our token-free model achives an format accuracy of 0.96, compared to 0.84 for token-based equivalents and 0.38 for GPT-4.