Soft robotic fingers can safely grasp fragile or non-uniform objects, but their force capacity is limited, especially with less contact area: objects which are smaller, not round, or where an enclosing grasp is not feasible. To improve force capacity, this paper considers two types of grip failure, slip and dynamic rotational stability. For slip, a Coulomb model for soft fingers based on total normal and tangential force is validated, identifying the effect of contact area, pressure, and grip position on effective Coulomb coefficient, normal force and transverse stiffness. For rotational stability, bulk stiffness of the fingers is used to develop conditions for dynamic stability about the initial grasp, and a condition for when the rotation leads to slip. Together, these models suggest contact area improves grip by increasing transverse stiffness and normal force. The models are validated in a range of grasp conditions, shown to predict the influence of object radius and finger distance on grip stability limits.