This paper introduces a novel anomaly detection (AD) problem that focuses on identifying `odd-looking' objects relative to the other instances within a scene. Unlike the traditional AD benchmarks, in our setting, anomalies in this context are scene-specific, defined by the regular instances that make up the majority. Since object instances are often partly visible from a single viewpoint, our setting provides multiple views of each scene as input. To provide a testbed for future research in this task, we introduce two benchmarks, ToysAD-8K and PartsAD-15K. We propose a novel method that generates 3D object-centric representations for each instance and detects the anomalous ones through a cross-examination between the instances. We rigorously analyze our method quantitatively and qualitatively in the presented benchmarks.