Most real-world applications that employ deep neural networks (DNNs) quantize them to low precision to reduce the compute needs. We present a method to improve the robustness of quantized DNNs to white-box adversarial attacks. We first tackle the limitation of deterministic quantization to fixed ``bins'' by introducing a differentiable Stochastic Quantizer (SQ). We explore the hypothesis that different quantizations may collectively be more robust than each quantized DNN. We formulate a training objective to encourage different quantized DNNs to learn different representations of the input image. The training objective captures diversity and accuracy via mutual information between ensemble members. Through experimentation, we demonstrate substantial improvement in robustness against $L_\infty$ attacks even if the attacker is allowed to backpropagate through SQ (e.g., > 50\% accuracy to PGD(5/255) on CIFAR10 without adversarial training), compared to vanilla DNNs as well as existing ensembles of quantized DNNs. We extend the method to detect attacks and generate robustness profiles in the adversarial information plane (AIP), towards a unified analysis of different threat models by correlating the MI and accuracy.