Exploring Linguistic Properties of Monolingual BERTs with Typological Classification among Languages

The overwhelming success of transformers is a real conundrum stimulating a compelling question: are these machines replicating some traditional linguistic models or discovering radically new theories? In this paper, we propose a novel standpoint to investigate this important question. Using typological similarities among languages, we aim to layer-wise compare transformers for different languages to observe whether these similarities emerge for particular layers. For this investigation, we propose to use Centered kernel alignment to measure similarity among weight matrices. We discovered that syntactic typological similarity is consistent with the similarity among weights in the middle layers. This finding confirms results obtained by syntactically probing BERT and, thus, gives an important confirmation that BERT is replicating traditional linguistic models.