Abstract:We address a variant of multi-agent path finding in continuous environment (CE-MAPF), where agents move along sets of smooth curves. Collisions between agents are resolved via avoidance in the space domain. A new Continuous Environment Conflict-Based Search (CE-CBS) algorithm is proposed in this work. CE-CBS combines conflict-based search (CBS) for the high-level search framework with RRT* for low-level path planning. The CE-CBS algorithm is tested under various settings on diverse CE-MAPF instances. Experimental results show that CE-CBS is competitive w.r.t. to other algorithms that consider continuous aspect in MAPF such as MAPF with continuous time.
Abstract:Counterexample guided abstraction refinement (CEGAR) represents a powerful symbolic technique for various tasks such as model checking and reachability analysis. Recently, CEGAR combined with Boolean satisfiability (SAT) has been applied for multi-agent path finding (MAPF), a problem where the task is to navigate agents from their start positions to given individual goal positions so that the agents do not collide with each other. The recent CEGAR approach used the initial abstraction of the MAPF problem where collisions between agents were omitted and were eliminated in subsequent abstraction refinements. We propose in this work a novel CEGAR-style solver for MAPF based on SAT in which some abstractions are deliberately left non-refined. This adds the necessity to post-process the answers obtained from the underlying SAT solver as these answers slightly differ from the correct MAPF solutions. Non-refining however yields order-of-magnitude smaller SAT encodings than those of the previous approach and speeds up the overall solving process making the SAT-based solver for MAPF competitive again in relevant benchmarks.
Abstract:Multi-agent path finding (MAPF) is a task of finding non-conflicting paths connecting agents' specified initial and goal positions in a shared environment. We focus on compilation-based solvers in which the MAPF problem is expressed in a different well established formalism such as mixed-integer linear programming (MILP), Boolean satisfiability (SAT), or constraint programming (CP). As the target solvers for these formalisms act as black-boxes it is challenging to integrate MAPF specific heuristics in the MAPF compilation-based solvers. We show in this work how the build a MAPF encoding for the target SAT solver in which domain specific heuristic knowledge is reflected. The heuristic knowledge is transferred to the SAT solver by selecting candidate paths for each agent and by constructing the encoding only for these candidate paths instead of constructing the encoding for all possible paths for an agent. The conducted experiments show that heuristically guided compilation outperforms the vanilla variants of the SAT-based MAPF solver.
Abstract:We study the planning and acting phase for the problem of multi-agent path finding (MAPF) in this paper. MAPF is a problem of navigating agents from their start positions to specified individual goal positions so that agents do not collide with each other. Specifically we focus on executing MAPF plans with a group of Crazyflies, small indoor quadcopters . We show how to modify the existing continuous time conflict-based search algorithm (CCBS) to produce plans that are suitable for execution with the quadcopters. The acting phase uses the the Loco positioning system to check if the plan is executed correctly. Our finding is that the CCBS algorithm allows for extensions that can produce safe plans for quadcopters, namely cylindrical protection zone around each quadcopter can be introduced at the planning level.
Abstract:In multi-agent path finding (MAPF), the task is to find non-conflicting paths for multiple agents from their initial positions to given individual goal positions. MAPF represents a classical artificial intelligence problem often addressed by heuristic-search. An important alternative to search-based techniques is compilation of MAPF to a different formalism such as Boolean satisfiability (SAT). Contemporary SAT-based approaches to MAPF regard the SAT solver as an external tool whose task is to return an assignment of all decision variables of a Boolean model of input MAPF. We present in this short paper a novel compilation scheme called DPLL(MAPF) in which the consistency checking of partial assignments of decision variables with respect to the MAPF rules is integrated directly into the SAT solver. This scheme allows for far more automated compilation where the SAT solver and the consistency checking procedure work together simultaneously to create the Boolean model and to search for its satisfying assignment.
Abstract:Multi-agent path finding (MAPF) attracts considerable attention in artificial intelligence community as well as in robotics, and other fields such as warehouse logistics. The task in the standard MAPF is to find paths through which agents can navigate from their starting positions to specified individual goal positions. The combination of two additional requirements makes the problem computationally challenging: (i) agents must not collide with each other and (ii) the paths must be optimal with respect to some objective. Two major approaches to optimal MAPF solving include (1) dedicated search-based methods, which solve MAPF directly, and (2) compilation-based methods that reduce a MAPF instance to an instance in a different well established formalism, for which an efficient solver exists. The compilation-based MAPF solving can benefit from advancements accumulated during the development of the target solver often decades long. We summarize and compare contemporary compilation-based solvers for MAPF using formalisms like ASP, MIP, and SAT. We show the lessons learned from past developments and current trends in the topic and discuss its wider impact.
Abstract:Path planning for multiple robots (MRPP) represents a task of finding non-colliding paths for robots through which they can navigate from their initial positions to specified goal positions. The problem is usually modeled using undirected graphs where robots move between vertices across edges. Contemporary optimal solving algorithms include dedicated search-based methods, that solve the problem directly, and compilation-based algorithms that reduce MRPP to a different formalism for which an efficient solver exists, such as constraint programming (CP), mixed integer programming (MIP), or Boolean satisfiability (SAT). In this paper, we enhance existing SAT-based algorithm for MRPP via spartification of the set of candidate paths for each robot from which target Boolean encoding is derived. Suggested sparsification of the set of paths led to smaller target Boolean formulae that can be constructed and solved faster while optimality guarantees of the approach have been kept.
Abstract:We introduce multi-goal multi agent path finding (MAPF$^{MG}$) which generalizes the standard discrete multi-agent path finding (MAPF) problem. While the task in MAPF is to navigate agents in an undirected graph from their starting vertices to one individual goal vertex per agent, MAPF$^{MG}$ assigns each agent multiple goal vertices and the task is to visit each of them at least once. Solving MAPF$^{MG}$ not only requires finding collision free paths for individual agents but also determining the order of visiting agent's goal vertices so that common objectives like the sum-of-costs are optimized. We suggest two novel algorithms using different paradigms to address MAPF$^{MG}$: a heuristic search-based search algorithm called Hamiltonian-CBS (HCBS) and a compilation-based algorithm built using the SMT paradigm, called SMT-Hamiltonian-CBS (SMT-HCBS). Experimental comparison suggests limitations of compilation-based approach.
Abstract:The At-Most-One (AMO) constraint is a special case of cardinality constraint that requires at most one variable from a set of Boolean variables to be set to TRUE. AMO is important for modeling problems as Boolean satisfiability (SAT) from domains where decision variables represent spatial or temporal placements of some objects that cannot share the same spatial or temporal slot. The AMO constraint can be used for more efficient representation and problem solving in mutex networks consisting of pair-wise mutual exclusions forbidding pairs of Boolean variable to be simultaneously TRUE. An on-line method for automated detection of cliques for efficient representation of incremental mutex networks where new mutexes arrive using AMOs is presented. A comparison of SAT-based problem solving in mutex networks represented by AMO constraints using various encodings is shown.
Abstract:Multi-agent path finding in continuous space and time with geometric agents MAPF$^\mathcal{R}$ is addressed in this paper. The task is to navigate agents that move smoothly between predefined positions to their individual goals so that they do not collide. We introduce a novel solving approach for obtaining makespan optimal solutions called SMT-CBS$^\mathcal{R}$ based on {\em satisfiability modulo theories} (SMT). The new algorithm combines collision resolution known from conflict-based search (CBS) with previous generation of incomplete SAT encodings on top of a novel scheme for selecting decision variables in a potentially uncountable search space. We experimentally compare SMT-CBS$^\mathcal{R}$ and previous CCBS algorithm for MAPF$^\mathcal{R}$.