EXAGREE: Towards Explanation Agreement in Explainable Machine Learning

Explanations in machine learning are critical for trust, transparency, and fairness. Yet, complex disagreements among these explanations limit the reliability and applicability of machine learning models, especially in high-stakes environments. We formalize four fundamental ranking-based explanation disagreement problems and introduce a novel framework, EXplanation AGREEment (EXAGREE), to bridge diverse interpretations in explainable machine learning, particularly from stakeholder-centered perspectives. Our approach leverages a Rashomon set for attribution predictions and then optimizes within this set to identify Stakeholder-Aligned Explanation Models (SAEMs) that minimize disagreement with diverse stakeholder needs while maintaining predictive performance. Rigorous empirical analysis on synthetic and real-world datasets demonstrates that EXAGREE reduces explanation disagreement and improves fairness across subgroups in various domains. EXAGREE not only provides researchers with a new direction for studying explanation disagreement problems but also offers data scientists a tool for making better-informed decisions in practical applications.

Practical Attribution Guidance for Rashomon Sets

Different prediction models might perform equally well (Rashomon set) in the same task, but offer conflicting interpretations and conclusions about the data. The Rashomon effect in the context of Explainable AI (XAI) has been recognized as a critical factor. Although the Rashomon set has been introduced and studied in various contexts, its practical application is at its infancy stage and lacks adequate guidance and evaluation. We study the problem of the Rashomon set sampling from a practical viewpoint and identify two fundamental axioms - generalizability and implementation sparsity that exploring methods ought to satisfy in practical usage. These two axioms are not satisfied by most known attribution methods, which we consider to be a fundamental weakness. We use the norms to guide the design of an $\epsilon$-subgradient-based sampling method. We apply this method to a fundamental mathematical problem as a proof of concept and to a set of practical datasets to demonstrate its ability compared with existing sampling methods.