In this paper, we analyze the performance of one- and two-sided amplitude shift keying (ASK) modulations in single-input single-output wireless communication aided by a reconfigurable intelligent surface (RIS). Two scenarios are considered for the channel conditions: a blocked direct channel between the transmitter and the receiver, and an unblocked one. For the receiver, a noncoherent maximum likelihood detector is proposed, which detects the transmitted data signal based on statistical knowledge of the channel. The system's performance is then evaluated by deriving the symbol error probability (SEP) for both scenarios using the proposed noncoherent receiver structures. We also present a novel optimization framework to obtain the optimal one- and two-sided ASK modulation schemes that minimize the SEP under constraints on the available average transmit power for both the blocked and unblocked direct channel scenarios. Our extensive numerical investigations showcase that the considered RIS-aided communication system achieves superior error performance with both derived SEP-optimal ASK modulation schemes as compared to respective traditional ASK modulation. It is also demonstrated that, between the two proposed modulation schemes, the two-sided one yields the best SEP. The error performance is further analyzed for different system parameters, providing a comprehensive performance investigation of RIS-assisted noncoherent wireless communication systems.