While machine learning methods excel at pattern recognition, they struggle with complex reasoning tasks in a scalable, algorithmic manner. Recent Deep Thinking methods show promise in learning algorithms that extrapolate: learning in smaller environments and executing the learned algorithm in larger environments. However, these works are limited to symmetrical tasks, where the input and output dimensionalities are the same. To address this gap, we propose NeuralThink, a new recurrent architecture that can consistently extrapolate to both symmetrical and asymmetrical tasks, where the dimensionality of the input and output are different. We contribute with a novel benchmark of asymmetrical tasks for extrapolation. We show that NeuralThink consistently outperforms the prior state-of-the-art Deep Thinking architectures, in regards to stable extrapolation to large observations from smaller training sizes.