Deep neural networks have significantly improved the performance of face forgery detection models in discriminating Artificial Intelligent Generated Content (AIGC). However, their security is significantly threatened by the injection of triggers during model training (i.e., backdoor attacks). Although existing backdoor defenses and manual data selection can mitigate those using human-eye-sensitive triggers, such as patches or adversarial noises, the more challenging natural backdoor triggers remain insufficiently researched. To further investigate natural triggers, we propose a novel analysis-by-synthesis backdoor attack against face forgery detection models, which embeds natural triggers in the latent space. We thoroughly study such backdoor vulnerability from two perspectives: (1) Model Discrimination (Optimization-Based Trigger): we adopt a substitute detection model and find the trigger by minimizing the cross-entropy loss; (2) Data Distribution (Custom Trigger): we manipulate the uncommon facial attributes in the long-tailed distribution to generate poisoned samples without the supervision from detection models. Furthermore, to completely evaluate the detection models towards the latest AIGC, we utilize both state-of-the-art StyleGAN and Stable Diffusion for trigger generation. Finally, these backdoor triggers introduce specific semantic features to the generated poisoned samples (e.g., skin textures and smile), which are more natural and robust. Extensive experiments show that our method is superior from three levels: (1) Attack Success Rate: ours achieves a high attack success rate (over 99%) and incurs a small model accuracy drop (below 0.2%) with a low poisoning rate (less than 3%); (2) Backdoor Defense: ours shows better robust performance when faced with existing backdoor defense methods; (3) Human Inspection: ours is less human-eye-sensitive from a comprehensive user study.