Recently Implicit Neural Representations (INRs) gained attention as a novel and effective representation for various data types. Thus far, prior work mostly focused on optimizing their reconstruction performance. This work investigates INRs from a novel perspective, i.e., as a tool for image compression. To this end, we propose the first comprehensive compression pipeline based on INRs including quantization, quantization-aware retraining and entropy coding. Encoding with INRs, i.e. overfitting to a data sample, is typically orders of magnitude slower. To mitigate this drawback, we leverage meta-learned initializations based on MAML to reach the encoding in fewer gradient updates which also generally improves rate-distortion performance of INRs. We find that our approach to source compression with INRs vastly outperforms similar prior work, is competitive with common compression algorithms designed specifically for images and closes the gap to state-of-the-art learned approaches based on Rate-Distortion Autoencoders. Moreover, we provide an extensive ablation study on the importance of individual components of our method which we hope facilitates future research on this novel approach to image compression.