We present generalizations of Newton's method that incorporate derivatives of an arbitrary order $d$ but maintain a polynomial dependence on dimension in their cost per iteration. At each step, our $d^{\text{th}}$-order method uses semidefinite programming to construct and minimize a sum of squares-convex approximation to the $d^{\text{th}}$-order Taylor expansion of the function we wish to minimize. We prove that our $d^{\text{th}}$-order method has local convergence of order $d$. This results in lower oracle complexity compared to the classical Newton method. We show on numerical examples that basins of attraction around local minima can get larger as $d$ increases. Under additional assumptions, we present a modified algorithm, again with polynomial cost per iteration, which is globally convergent and has local convergence of order $d$.