Can Bio-Inspired Swarm Algorithms Scale to Modern Societal Problems

Taking inspiration from nature for meta-heuristics has proven popular and relatively successful. Many are inspired by the collective intelligence exhibited by insects, fish and birds. However, there is a question over their scalability to the types of complex problems experienced in the modern world. Natural systems evolved to solve simpler problems effectively, replicating these processes for complex problems may suffer from inefficiencies. Several causal factors can impact scalability; computational complexity, memory requirements or pure problem intractability. Supporting evidence is provided using a case study in Ant Colony Optimisation (ACO) regards tackling increasingly complex real-world fleet optimisation problems. This paper hypothesizes that contrary to common intuition, bio-inspired collective intelligence techniques by their very nature exhibit poor scalability in cases of high dimensionality when large degrees of decision making are required. Facilitating scaling of bio-inspired algorithms necessitates reducing this decision making. To support this hypothesis, an enhanced Partial-ACO technique is presented which effectively reduces ant decision making. Reducing the decision making required by ants by up to 90% results in markedly improved effectiveness and reduced runtimes for increasingly complex fleet optimisation problems. Reductions in traversal timings of 40-50% are achieved for problems with up to 45 vehicles and 437 jobs.

Applying Partial-ACO to Large-scale Vehicle Fleet Optimisation

Optimisation of fleets of commercial vehicles with regards scheduling tasks from various locations to vehicles can result in considerably lower fleet traversal times. This has significant benefits including reduced expenses for the company and more importantly, a reduction in the degree of road use and hence vehicular emissions. Exact optimisation methods fail to scale to real commercial problem instances, thus meta-heuristics are more suitable. Ant Colony Optimisation (ACO) generally provides good solutions on small to medium problem sizes. However, commercial fleet optimisation problems are typically large and complex, in which ACO fails to scale well. Partial-ACO is a new ACO variant designed to scale to larger problem instances. Therefore this paper investigates the application of Partial-ACO on the problem of fleet optimisation, demonstrating the capacity of Partial-ACO to successfully scale to larger problems. Indeed, for real-world fleet optimisation problems supplied by a Birmingham based company with up to 298 jobs and 32 vehicles, Partial-ACO can improve upon their fleet traversal times by over 44%. Moreover, Partial-ACO demonstrates its ability to scale with considerably improved results over standard ACO and competitive results against a Genetic Algorithm.