This paper provides a robust, scalable Bluetooth Low-Energy (BLE) based indoor localization solution using commodity hardware. While WiFi-based indoor localization has been widely studied, BLE has emerged a key technology for contact-tracing in the current pandemic. To accurately estimate distance using BLE on commercial devices, systems today rely on Receiver Signal Strength Indicator(RSSI) which suffers from sampling bias and multipath effects. We propose a new metric: Packet Reception Probability (PRP) that builds on a counter-intuitive idea that we can exploit packet loss to estimate distance. We localize using a Bayesian-PRP formulation that also incorporates an explicit model of the multipath. To make deployment easy, we do not require any hardware, firmware, or driver-level changes to off-the-shelf devices, and require minimal training. PRP can achieve meter level accuracy with just 6 devices with known locations and 12 training locations. We show that fusing PRP with RSSI is beneficial at short distances < 2m. Beyond 2m, fusion is worse than PRP, as RSSI becomes effectively de-correlated with distance. Robust location accuracy at all distances and ease of deployment with PRP can help enable wide range indoor localization solutions using BLE.