We present an empirical study on embedding the lyrics of a song into a fixed-dimensional feature for the purpose of music tagging. Five methods of computing token-level and four methods of computing document-level representations are trained on an industrial-scale dataset of tens of millions of songs. We compare simple averaging of pretrained embeddings to modern recurrent and attention-based neural architectures. Evaluating on a wide range of tagging tasks such as genre classification, explicit content identification and era detection, we find that averaging word embeddings outperform more complex architectures in many downstream metrics.