Improving a tf-idf weighted document vector embedding

We examine a number of methods to compute a dense vector embedding for a document in a corpus, given a set of word vectors such as those from word2vec or GloVe. We describe two methods that can improve upon a simple weighted sum, that are optimal in the sense that they maximizes a particular weighted cosine similarity measure. We consider several weighting functions, including inverse document frequency (idf), smooth inverse frequency (SIF), and the sub-sampling function used in word2vec. We find that idf works best for our applications. We also use common component removal proposed by Arora et al. as a post-process and find it is helpful in most cases. We compare these embeddings variations to the doc2vec embedding on a new evaluation task using TripAdvisor reviews, and also on the CQADupStack benchmark from the literature.