Evaluation in Neural Style Transfer: A Review

The field of Neural Style Transfer (NST) has witnessed remarkable progress in the past few years, with approaches being able to synthesize artistic and photorealistic images and videos of exceptional quality. To evaluate such results, a diverse landscape of evaluation methods and metrics is used, including authors' opinions based on side-by-side comparisons, human evaluation studies that quantify the subjective judgements of participants, and a multitude of quantitative computational metrics which objectively assess the different aspects of an algorithm's performance. However, there is no consensus regarding the most suitable and effective evaluation procedure that can guarantee the reliability of the results. In this review, we provide an in-depth analysis of existing evaluation techniques, identify the inconsistencies and limitations of current evaluation methods, and give recommendations for standardized evaluation practices. We believe that the development of a robust evaluation framework will not only enable more meaningful and fairer comparisons among NST methods but will also enhance the comprehension and interpretation of research findings in the field.

Neural Style Transfer for Computer Games

Neural Style Transfer (NST) research has been applied to images, videos, 3D meshes and radiance fields, but its application to 3D computer games remains relatively unexplored. Whilst image and video NST systems can be used as a post-processing effect for a computer game, this results in undesired artefacts and diminished post-processing effects. Here, we present an approach for injecting depth-aware NST as part of the 3D rendering pipeline. Qualitative and quantitative experiments are used to validate our in-game stylisation framework. We demonstrate temporally consistent results of artistically stylised game scenes, outperforming state-of-the-art image and video NST methods.

Depth-aware Neural Style Transfer using Instance Normalization

Neural Style Transfer (NST) is concerned with the artistic stylization of visual media. It can be described as the process of transferring the style of an artistic image onto an ordinary photograph. Recently, a number of studies have considered the enhancement of the depth-preserving capabilities of the NST algorithms to address the undesired effects that occur when the input content images include numerous objects at various depths. Our approach uses a deep residual convolutional network with instance normalization layers that utilizes an advanced depth prediction network to integrate depth preservation as an additional loss function to content and style. We demonstrate results that are effective in retaining the depth and global structure of content images. Three different evaluation processes show that our system is capable of preserving the structure of the stylized results while exhibiting style-capture capabilities and aesthetic qualities comparable or superior to state-of-the-art methods.