In this work, we investigate people's engagement and attitudes towards a non-anthropomorphic robot manipulator that initiates small talk with the user during a collaborative assembly task, and explore how the presence of negative team feedback may affect team dynamics and blame attribution. Through an exploratory study with 20 participants, we found that 18 individuals interacted socially with the robot, nine of which initiated questions back to the robot. We report the frequency and length of users' responses in task-oriented and non-task-oriented dialogue, and further elaborate on people's reactions to the negative system feedback and robot-initiated small talk. We discuss the potential for integrating small talk in non-social robots, and propose three design guidelines to enhance human-robot small talk interactions.