In an era of information overload and complex decision-making processes, Recommender Systems (RS) have emerged as indispensable tools across diverse domains, particularly travel and tourism. These systems simplify trip planning by offering personalized recommendations that consider individual preferences and address broader challenges like seasonality, travel regulations, and capacity constraints. The intricacies of the tourism domain, characterized by multiple stakeholders, including consumers, item providers, platforms, and society, underscore the complexity of achieving balance among diverse interests. Although previous research has focused on fairness in Tourism Recommender Systems (TRS) from a multistakeholder perspective, limited work has focused on generating sustainable recommendations. Our paper introduces a novel approach for assigning a sustainability indicator (SF index) for city trips accessible from the users' starting point, integrating Co2e analysis, destination popularity, and seasonal demand. Our methodology involves comprehensive data gathering on transportation modes and emissions, complemented by analyses of destination popularity and seasonal demand. A user study validates our index, showcasing its practicality and efficacy in providing well-rounded and sustainable city trip recommendations. Our findings contribute significantly to the evolution of responsible tourism strategies, harmonizing the interests of tourists, local communities, and the environment while paving the way for future research in responsible and equitable tourism practices.